Tumor Area Positivity : a novel visual estimation method for combined tumor cell and immune cell scoring

• Published in: Diagnostic pathology Vol. 18; no. 1
• Main Authors: Liu, Chunyan, Fang, Fang, Kong, Ying, ElGabry, Ehab A
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: BioMed Central Ltd 19-04-2023
• Subjects: Algorithms; Immunotherapy; Medical equipment and supplies industry; Medical test kit industry; Methods; Tumors; United States
• ISSN: 1746-1596; 1746-1596
• DOI: 10.1186/s13000-023-01318-8

Background Determination of programmed death-ligand 1 (PD-L1) protein expression level in tumor cells and tumor-associated immune cells is critical for identifying patients eligible for immunotherapy. PD-L1 manual scoring algorithms can generally be divided into two categories: cell counting and visual estimation. Cell counting can be time-consuming and is not in sync with pathology practice, which classically uses a Gestalt approach based on pattern recognition and visual estimation. In this study, we introduce the Tumor Area Positivity (TAP) score, which is a novel, straightforward method for scoring tumor cells and immune cells together using visual estimation. Methods To demonstrate the reproducibility of TAP scoring among pathologists, between- and within-reader precision studies were performed both within (internal) and outside of (external) our organization. We also compared the TAP score to the Combined Positive Score (CPS), which is based on cell counting, for concordance and time efficacy. Results The average positive agreement, average negative agreement, and overall percent agreement between and within readers were all above 85% for both internal and combined external reader precision studies. TAP score had high concordance rate at 5% cutoff compared with CPS at cutoff 1: positive percent agreement, negative percent agreement, and overall percent agreement were all above 85%. Conclusions Our study showed the TAP scoring method to be straightforward, significantly less time-consuming, and highly reproducible with a high concordance rate between TAP score and CPS. Keywords: Programmed death-ligand 1 (PD-L1), Tumor area positivity, Tumor cells, Immune cells, Scoring method