MS Bodl. Canon. Pat. Lat. 131 and a Lost Lactantius of John of Salisbury: Evidence in Search of a French Critic of Thomas Becket

• Published in: Albion (Boone) Vol. 22; no. 1; pp. 21 - 37
• Main Author: Barker, Lynn K.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Boone, N.C Appalachian State University 01-04-1990; Appalachian State University, etc
• Subjects: Abbots; Anthologies; Archbishops; Bibliographies; Cataloging; Chancellors; Clerics; Exile; Libraries; The 1987 Denis Bethell Prize Essay of the Charles Homer Haskins Society
• ISSN: 0095-1390; 2326-1242
• DOI: 10.2307/4050255

The
English Historical Review
for 1974 published an intriguing proposal by Braxton Ross concerning the early history of Bodleian MS Canon. Pat. Lat. 131, a twelfth-century copy of Lactantius'
Divine Institutes
. Ross noticed several marginalia that read “
Audi Thoma
” or “
Henriciani Nota
,” and he suggested that these might have been penned by an unknown French cleric who wished to criticize Henry II's chancellor, Thomas Becket. From fourteenth-century writings contained on the manuscript's fly-leaves, scholars have long recognized the Bodleian Lactantius as once having been the property of Landolfo Colonna, a canon at Chartres in the years 1298–1328. On paleographical grounds, Ross assigns the manuscript's provenance to central France in the twelfth century. Noting that the
Istitutiones Divinae
was a rare text at the time — apparently unknown in England from Alcuin's day until the fourteenth century — and that this “utilitarian” yet “handsome” manuscript was made using two exemplars, Ross concludes that the Bodleian Lactantius originated in “a centre of intellectual vigour and wide-ranging connections.” Three hands corrected the text, all at the site of production. One of these hands has left many remarks that (Ross felt) display the annotator's wide classical and patristic reading and, as the “
Audi Thoma
” notes seem to suggest, an interest in Thomas Becket and the “Henricians.”