"If it is not made easy for me, I will just not bother". A qualitative exploration of the barriers and facilitators to recycling plastics

• Published in: PloS one Vol. 17; no. 5; p. e0267284
• Main Authors: Roy, Deborah, Berry, Emma, Dempster, Martin
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Public Library of Science 03-05-2022; Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subjects: Adult; Adults; Analysis; Biology and Life Sciences; Cognitive ability; Consumer behavior; Consumers; Content analysis; Environmental perception; Frequency analysis; Garbage collection; Humans; Influence; Interviews; Local government; Medicine and Health Sciences; Motivation; Packaging; Physical Sciences; Plastic debris; Plastics; Plastics recycling; Polyethylene terephthalate; Product Packaging; Psychological factors; Qualitative research; Recycled materials; Recycling; Recycling centers; Refuse Disposal; Research and Analysis Methods; Scaffolding; Social networks; Social Sciences; Surveys; Visual stimuli; Waste disposal; Waste Management; Waste materials; United Kingdom
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0267284

Despite significant investment to increase recycling facilities and kerbside collection of waste materials, plastic packaging is frequently discarded as litter, resulting in significant environmental harm. This research uses qualitative methods to explore the contextual and psychological factors that influence plastic waste disposal behaviour from the perspectives of consumers. This research also reports key results from a brief online survey exploring consumer perspectives toward plastics and plastic recycling. A total of N = 18 adults living in Northern Ireland (NI) participated in a semi-structured interview and N = 756 adults living in NI took part in an online survey. Interview data was analysed via a semi-directed content analysis approach, using the COM-B behaviour change model as a guiding framework. Survey data underwent descriptive and frequency analysis. Collectively, the findings suggest that environmental concern exists among consumers generally, but there is a degree of ambivalence toward recycling that reflects a gap between intentions to recycle and actual recycling behaviour. Plastic recycling behaviour is hindered by three common barriers: 1. confusion and uncertainty about which plastic materials can be recycled (exacerbated by the abundance of plastic products available) 2. perceiving plastic recycling to be less of a personal priority in daily life 3. perceiving that local government and manufacturers have a responsibility to make plastic recycling easier. As recycling is simply not a priority for many individuals, efforts should instead be placed on providing greater scaffolding to make the process of recycling less tedious, confusing, and more habitual. Visual cues on product packing and recycling resources can address ambiguity about which plastic materials can/cannot be recycled and increasing opportunities to recycle (via consistent availability of recycling bins) can reduce the physical burden of accessing recycling resources. Such interventions, based on environmental restructuring and enablement, may increase motivations to recycle by reducing the cognitive and physical burden of recycling, supporting healthier recycling habits.