Cultural sensitivity in brain death determination: a necessity in end-of-life decisions in Japan

• Published in: BMC medical ethics Vol. 22; no. 1; p. 58
• Main Authors: Terunuma, Yuri, Mathis, Bryan J
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England BioMed Central Ltd 13-05-2021; BioMed Central; BMC
• Subjects: Bioethics; Blood & organ donations; Brain death; Brain injury; Clinical medicine; Culture; Debate; Demographic aspects; End-of-life issues; Ethical aspects; Health policy; Informed consent (Medical law); Japanese culture; Law; Laws, regulations and rules; Management; Medical ethics; Medical practices; Medicine; Norms; Social aspects; Society; Terminal care; Transplants & implants; South Korea; Japan; China; Asia; End-of-life issues; Health policy; Law; Brain injury; Culture
• ISSN: 1472-6939; 1472-6939
• DOI: 10.1186/s12910-021-00626-2

In an increasingly globalized world, legal protocols related to health care that are both effective and culturally sensitive are paramount in providing excellent quality of care as well as protection for physicians tasked with decision making. Here, we analyze the current medicolegal status of brain death diagnosis with regard to end-of-life care in Japan, China, and South Korea from the perspectives of front-line health care workers.
Japan has legally wrestled with the concept of brain death for decades. An inability to declare brain death without consent from family coupled with cultural expectations of family involvement in medical care is mirrored in other Confucian-based cultures (China and South Korea) and may complicate care for patients from these countries when traveling or working overseas. Within Japan, China, and South Korea, medicolegal shortcomings in the diagnosis of brain death (and organ donation) act as a great source of stress for physicians and expose them to potential public and legal scorn. Here, we detail the medicolegal status of brain death diagnosis within Japan and compare it to China and South Korea to find common ground and elucidate the impact of legal ambiguity on health care workers.
The Confucian cultural foundation of multiple Asian countries raises common issues of family involvement with diagnosis and cultural considerations that must be met. Leveraging public education systems may increase awareness of brain death issues and lead to evolving laws that clarify such end-of-life issues while protecting physicians from sociocultural backlash.