Repairing boundaries along pathways to tuberculosis case detection: a qualitative synthesis of intervention designs

• Published in: Health research policy and systems Vol. 20; no. 1; p. 7
• Main Authors: van Wyk, Susanna S, Medley, Nancy, Young, Taryn, Oliver, Sandy
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England BioMed Central Ltd 10-01-2022; BioMed Central; BMC
• Subjects: Analysis; Clinical trials; Descriptions; Health care facilities; Health Personnel; Health promotion; Health services; HIV; HIV Infections; Human immunodeficiency virus; Humans; Infectious disease screening; Intervention; Logic; Mass Screening; Medical screening; Missing tuberculosis cases; Patient Acceptance of Health Care; Patients; Policy making; Qualitative research; Review; Screening; Synthesis; Terminology; Tuberculosis; Tuberculosis care pathways; Tuberculosis case detection; Tuberculosis case finding; Tuberculosis screening; Tuberculosis case finding; Tuberculosis care pathways; Missing tuberculosis cases; Infectious disease screening; Tuberculosis screening; Logic model; Tuberculosis case detection
• ISSN: 1478-4505; 1478-4505
• DOI: 10.1186/s12961-021-00811-0

Tuberculosis case-finding interventions often involve several activities to enhance patient pathways, and it is unclear which activity defines the type of case-finding intervention. When conducting studies to identify the most effective case-finding intervention it is important to have a clear understanding of these interventions for meaningful comparisons. This review aimed to construct a systems-based logic model of all pathways to tuberculosis case detection through a synthesis of intervention designs.
We identified an existing systematic review on the effectiveness of interventions to increase tuberculosis case detection and updated the search from December 2016 to October 2020. We included randomized controlled trials, as these designs encourage detailed description of interventions. Taking each study in turn, intervention descriptions were read in detail. The texts were analysed qualitatively by constantly comparing emerging codes to construct patient journeys, visualized as logical chains. Actions taken as part of interventions were positioned along patient journeys to theorize the sequence of outcomes. Patient journeys formed the basis of the model, which was refined through discussion.
Based on intervention descriptions from 17 randomized controlled trials, our model distinguishes two care-seeking pathways and four screening pathways. An open invitation to people with tuberculosis symptoms creates care-seeking pathways. On care-seeking pathways, systematic screening can be conducted at general health services, but not at specific TB care services. People invited to tuberculosis services regardless of symptoms follow tuberculosis screening pathways and may be identified with presumptive tuberculosis even if they do not seek care for tuberculosis symptoms. Tuberculosis screening pathways include screening offered to all people accessing care at general health services, screening at a mobile clinic or health facility with open invitation to a whole population or tuberculosis contacts, screening personally offered to a whole population or tuberculosis contacts at home, work or school, and screening offered to people receiving care for human immunodeficiency virus or other clinical risk-group care.
This systems-based logic model of tuberculosis case-finding pathways may support standardized terminology, consistency, transparency and improved communication among researchers, policy-makers, health workers and community members when implementing and evaluating interventions to improve tuberculosis case detection.