The cost of implementing the Systems Analysis and Improvement Approach for a cluster randomized trial integrating HIV testing into family planning services in Mombasa County, Kenya

• Published in: BMC health services research Vol. 22; no. 1; p. 1480
• Main Authors: Thomas, Dorothy, Wanje, George, Eastment, McKenna C, McClelland, R Scott, Mwaringa, Emily, Patta, Shem, Jaoko, Walter, Kinuthia, John, Abubakar, Aisha, Sherr, Kenneth, Barnabas, Ruanne V
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England BioMed Central Ltd 05-12-2022; BioMed Central; BMC
• Subjects: Access control; Age; Analysis; Cost analysis; Cost estimates; Data collection; Diagnosis; Disease transmission; Family planning; Family Planning Services; Female; Health care management; Health facilities; Health services; HIV; HIV infection; HIV Infections - diagnosis; HIV Infections - prevention & control; HIV Testing; Human immunodeficiency virus; Humans; Kenya; Management; Maternal & child health; Medical care, Cost of; Medical tests; Methods; Prevention; Reproductive health; Systems Analysis; Systems analysis and improvement approach (SAIA); Women; Kenya; Mombasa Kenya; Prevention; Women; Family planning; Systems analysis and improvement approach (SAIA); HIV; Cost analysis
• ISSN: 1472-6963; 1472-6963
• DOI: 10.1186/s12913-022-08828-z

Although HIV testing in family planning (FP) clinics is a promising approach for engaging women in HIV treatment and prevention services, HIV testing rates are low in FP clinics in Kenya. In 2018, a cluster randomized trial was implemented in Mombasa, Kenya applying the Systems Analysis and Improvement Approach (SAIA) to integrate HIV testing into FP services (1K24HD088229-01). We estimated the incremental costs and explored cost drivers of the FP HIV SAIA implementation in Mombasa, Kenya.
We conducted a costing evaluation from the payer perspective for the FP HIV SAIA randomized control trial. We identified relevant activities for the intervention including start-up, training, research and FP HIV SAIA. We estimated activity time burden using a time-and motion study. We derived unit costs through staff interviews and programmatic budgets. We present cost estimates for two different scenarios: as-implemented including research and projected costs for a Ministry of Health-supported intervention. All costs are reported in 2018 USD.
For an annual program output of 36,086 HIV tests administered to new FP clients, we estimated the total annual program cost to be $91,994 with an average cost per new FP client served of $2.55. Personnel and HIV rapid testing kits comprised 55% and 21% of programmatic costs, respectively. Assuming no changes to program outputs and with efficiency gains under the MOH scenario, the estimated cost per new FP client served decreased to $1.30 with a programmatic cost reduction of 49%.
FP HIV SAIA is a low-cost and flexible implementation strategy for facilitating integrated delivery of HIV testing alongside FP services. Although cost implications of the FP HIV SAIA intervention must continue to be evaluated over time, these findings provide context-specific cost data useful for budget planning and decision-making regarding intervention delivery and expansion.
The trial was registered on December 15, 2016, with clinicaltrials.gov (NCT02994355).