Functional diversity through the mean trait dissimilarity: resolving shortcomings with existing paradigms and algorithms

• Published in: Oecologia Vol. 180; no. 4; pp. 933 - 940
• Main Authors: de Bello, Francesco, Carmona, Carlos P, Lepš, Jan, Szava-Kovats, Robert, Pärtel, Meelis
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Berlin/Heidelberg Springer Berlin Heidelberg 01-04-2016; Springer Science + Business Media; Springer; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Algorithms; Biodiversity; Biomedical and Life Sciences; ecologists; Ecology; Ecology - standards; entropy; functional diversity; Hydrology/Water Resources; Life Sciences; Models, Biological; Phenotype; Plant Sciences; selection index; SPECIAL TOPIC ON FUNCTIONAL TRAITS; Assembly rules; Phylogenetic diversity; Biodiversity indices; Trait variance; Community
• ISSN: 0029-8549; 1432-1939
• DOI: 10.1007/s00442-016-3546-0

While an increasing number of indices for estimating the functional trait diversity of biological communities are being proposed, there is a growing demand by ecologists to clarify their actual implications and simplify index selection. Several key indices relate to mean trait dissimilarity between species within biological communities. Among them, the most widely used include (a) the mean species pairwise dissimilarity (MPD) and (b) the Rao quadratic entropy (and related indices). These indices are often regarded as redundant and promote the unsubstantiated yet widely held view that Rao is a form of MPD. Worryingly, existing R functions also do not always simplify the use and differentiation of these indices. In this paper, we show various distinctions between these two indices that warrant mathematical and biological consideration. We start by showing an existing form of MPD that considers species abundances and is different from Rao both mathematically and conceptually. We then show that the mathematical relationship between MPD and Rao can be presented simply as Rao = MPD × Simpson, where the Simpson diversity index is defined as 1 − dominance. We further show that this relationship is maintained for both species abundances and presence/absence. This evidence dismantles the paradigm that the Rao diversity is an abundance-weighted form of MPD and indicates that both indices can differ substantially at low species diversities. We discuss the different interpretations of trait diversity patterns in biological communities provided by Rao and MPD and then provide a simple R function, called “melodic,” which avoids the unintended results that arise from existing mainstream functions.