An empirical comparison of neural networks and machine learning algorithms for EEG gait decoding

• Published in: Scientific reports Vol. 10; no. 1; p. 4372
• Main Authors: Nakagome, Sho, Luu, Trieu Phat, He, Yongtian, Ravindran, Akshay Sujatha, Contreras-Vidal, Jose L.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London Nature Publishing Group UK 09-03-2020; Nature Publishing Group
• Subjects: 631/378/116/2394; 631/378/2632/2634; Algorithms; Brain-Computer Interfaces; Computational neuroscience; EEG; Electroencephalography; Gait; Humanities and Social Sciences; Humans; Interfaces; Kinematics; Learning algorithms; Machine Learning; multidisciplinary; Neural networks; Neural Networks, Computer; Science; Science (multidisciplinary)
• ISSN: 2045-2322; 2045-2322
• DOI: 10.1038/s41598-020-60932-4

Previous studies of Brain Computer Interfaces (BCI) based on scalp electroencephalography (EEG) have demonstrated the feasibility of decoding kinematics for lower limb movements during walking. In this computational study, we investigated offline decoding analysis with different models and conditions to assess how they influence the performance and stability of the decoder. Specifically, we conducted three computational decoding experiments that investigated decoding accuracy: (1) based on delta band time-domain features, (2) when downsampling data, (3) of different frequency band features. In each experiment, eight different decoder algorithms were compared including the current state-of-the-art. Different tap sizes (sample window sizes) were also evaluated for a real-time applicability assessment. A feature of importance analysis was conducted to ascertain which features were most relevant for decoding; moreover, the stability to perturbations was assessed to quantify the robustness of the methods. Results indicated that generally the Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU) and Quasi Recurrent Neural Network (QRNN) outperformed other methods in terms of decoding accuracy and stability. Previous state-of-the-art Unscented Kalman Filter (UKF) still outperformed other decoders when using smaller tap sizes, with fast convergence in performance, but occurred at a cost to noise vulnerability. Downsampling and the inclusion of other frequency band features yielded overall improvement in performance. The results suggest that neural network-based decoders with downsampling or a wide range of frequency band features could not only improve decoder performance but also robustness with applications for stable use of BCIs.