Uncertainty quantification of reference-based cellular deconvolution algorithms

• Published in: Epigenetics Vol. 18; no. 1; p. 2137659
• Main Authors: Vellame, Dorothea Seiler, Shireby, Gemma, MacCalman, Ailsa, Dempster, Emma L, Burrage, Joe, Gorrie-Stone, Tyler, Schalkwyk, Leonard S, Mill, Jonathan, Hannon, Eilis
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Taylor & Francis 31-12-2023; Taylor & Francis Group
• Subjects: Algorithms; cellular heterogeneity; Computational Biology - methods; DNA Methylation; epigenetic epidemiology; Epigenomics; Female; Humans; illumina 450K array; Illumina EPIC array; Infant, Newborn; Research Paper; Uncertainty; DNA methylation; epigenetic epidemiology; cellular heterogeneity; Illumina EPIC array; illumina 450K array
• ISSN: 1559-2294; 1559-2308
• DOI: 10.1080/15592294.2022.2137659

The majority of epigenetic epidemiology studies to date have generated genome-wide profiles from bulk tissues (e.g., whole blood) however these are vulnerable to confounding from variation in cellular composition. Proxies for cellular composition can be mathematically derived from the bulk tissue profiles using a deconvolution algorithm; however, there is no method to assess the validity of these estimates for a dataset where the true cellular proportions are unknown. In this study, we describe, validate and characterize a sample level accuracy metric for derived cellular heterogeneity variables. The CETYGO score captures the deviation between a sample's DNA methylation profile and its expected profile given the estimated cellular proportions and cell type reference profiles. We demonstrate that the CETYGO score consistently distinguishes inaccurate and incomplete deconvolutions when applied to reconstructed whole blood profiles. By applying our novel metric to >6,300 empirical whole blood profiles, we find that estimating accurate cellular composition is influenced by both technical and biological variation. In particular, we show that when using a common reference panel for whole blood, less accurate estimates are generated for females, neonates, older individuals and smokers. Our results highlight the utility of a metric to assess the accuracy of cellular deconvolution, and describe how it can enhance studies of DNA methylation that are reliant on statistical proxies for cellular heterogeneity. To facilitate incorporating our methodology into existing pipelines, we have made it freely available as an R package (
https://github.com/ds420/CETYGO
).