Skin Quality - A Holistic 360° View: Consensus Results

• Published in: Clinical, cosmetic and investigational dermatology Vol. 14; pp. 643 - 654
• Main Authors: Goldie, Kate, Kerscher, Martina, Fabi, Sabrina Guillen, Hirano, Cyro, Landau, Marina, Lim, Ting Song, Woolery-Lloyd, Heather, Mariwalla, Kavita, Park, Je-Young, Yutskovskaya, Yana
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: New Zealand Dove Medical Press Limited 2021; Taylor & Francis Ltd; Dove; Dove Medical Press
• Subjects: aesthetic treatment; Age groups; Aging; Botulinum toxin; consensus; COVID-19; Dermatology; emergent perceptual skin quality categories; epcs; Ethnicity; Glycerol; Hyaluronic acid; Hydration; Hydroxyapatite; Hydroxylapatite; Medical care; Original Research; Quality management; Skin; skin quality; Ultrasonic imaging; Viscoelasticity; Visualization; Germany; United States > US; North America; consensus; emergent perceptual skin quality categories; aesthetic treatment; EPCs; skin quality
• ISSN: 1178-7015; 1178-7015
• DOI: 10.2147/CCID.S309374

Skin quality is an important component of human attractiveness. To date, there are no standardized criteria for good skin quality. To establish a consensus for good skin quality parameters and measurement and treatment options, a virtual skin quality advisory board consisting of a global panel of highly experienced aesthetic dermatologists/aesthetic physicians was convened.
A total of 10 dermatologists/aesthetic physicians served on the advisory board. A modified version of the Delphi method was used to arrive at consensus. Members accessed an online platform to review statements on skin quality criteria from their peers, including treatment and measurement options, and voted to indicate whether they agreed or disagreed. Statements that did not have agreement were modified and the members voted again. Consensus was defined as: strong consensus = greater than 95% agreement; consensus = 75% to 95% agreement; majority consent = 50% to 75% agreement; no consensus = less than 50% agreement.
There was strong consensus that good skin quality is defined as healthy, youthful in appearance (appearing younger than a person's chronological age), undamaged skin and that skin quality can be described across all ethnicities by four emergent perceptual categories (EPCs): skin tone evenness, skin surface evenness, skin firmness, and skin glow. The EPCs can be affected by multiple tissue layers (ie, skin surface quality can stem from and be impacted by deep structures or tissues). This means that topical approaches may not be sufficient. Instead, improving skin quality EPCs can require a multilayer treatment strategy.
This global advisory board established strong consensus that skin quality can be described by four EPCs, which can help clinicians determine the appropriate treatment option(s) and the tissue or skin layer(s) to address. Skin quality is important to human health and wellbeing and patients' perception for the need for aesthetic treatment.