Do nurses risk underestimating the problems of patients with frontal lobe neoplasms?

• Published in: European journal of oncology nursing : the official journal of European Oncology Nursing Society Vol. 16; no. 2; pp. 158 - 164
• Main Authors: Palese, Alvisa, Romano, Alessia, Moreale, Renzo, Magee, Jesse
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Scotland Elsevier Ltd 01-04-2012
• Subjects: Accuracy; Adult; Aged; Aged, 80 and over; Brain; Brain Neoplasms - nursing; Cancer; Cerebral neoplasm; Clinical judgment; Concordance; Female; Frontal Lobe; Frontal lobe neoplasm; Frontal lobes; Hematology, Oncology and Palliative Medicine; Humans; Italy; Male; Middle Aged; Nurses; Nursing; Nursing Assessment - standards; Nursing Evaluation Research; Patient’s perceptions; Prospective Studies; Risk Assessment; Tumours; Young Adult; Italy; Accuracy; Concordance; Italy; Clinical judgment; Cerebral neoplasm; Patient’s perceptions; Frontal lobe neoplasm
• ISSN: 1462-3889; 1532-2122
• DOI: 10.1016/j.ejon.2011.04.014

Abstract Purpose Although the profile of the problems and risks associated with cancer patients has expanded over the past few years, and so has our available knowledge on the concordance between patients and nurses, there is a lack of evidence concerning neurosurgical patients. In comparison with patients who have neoplasm located in other lobes, those with frontal lobe cancer can suffer from personality changes, disinhibition, apathy, and higher-order attentional difficulties. Such behavior may give rise to a stigma, and consequently, pose a risk to have their problems misunderstood by caregivers, and be at greater risk than they are perceived to be. Objective To explore the risk of nurses underestimating the problems of patients who were operated on for frontal neoplasm, compared to patients suffering from neoplasms located in other cerebral lobes. Methods A prospective study was undertaken in 2008 in Italy. Patients admitted to the hospital with brain neoplasm were eligible for the study. For each patient with a frontal lobe neoplasm, a corresponding patient with a cerebral neoplasm located in either the temporal, parietal or occipital lobes was also included. Nurses working in the units involved and providing care to these patients were also included. On the afternoon of the 2nd postoperative day, the researcher interviewed both the patients, and the registered nurses (RNs) responsible for the patients’ care, in regards to pain intensity, dependence in activities of daily living, anxiety and depression, and fear of falling, as each was perceived by patients and nurses. The level of concordance between the patients’ and nurses’ responses was calculated. Results Forty-six patients were considered (mean age 53.5 years); 23 had surgery for a frontal brain neoplasm and 23 for brain neoplasms located in either the temporal, parietal, or occipital areas. Overall, patients operated on for frontal lobe neoplasms had much of the same risks of underestimation of their problems, as patients with other cerebral neoplasms. Conclusions Patients with frontal lobe neoplasms seemed, overall, to run the same risk of their problems being underestimated as patients with cerebral neoplasms located at other sites. Neurosurgical nurses tended to overestimate patients’ problems, particularly in cases with neoplasms not located in the frontal lobe. This unexpected finding needs to be addressed with further research, and might warrant a different approach to caring for patients with frontal lobe neoplasms, whose problems are overestimated less, so that they might receive less supportive care.