Diffusion of excellence: evaluating a system to identify, replicate, and spread promising innovative practices across the Veterans health administration

• Published in: Frontiers in health services Vol. 3; p. 1223277
• Main Authors: Jackson, George L, Fix, Gemmae M, White, Brandolyn S, Cutrona, Sarah L, Reardon, Caitlin M, Damschroder, Laura J, Burns, Madison, DeLaughter, Kathryn, Opra Widerquist, Marilla A, Arasim, Maria, Lindquist, Jennifer, Gifford, Allen L, King, Heather A, Kaitz, Jenesse, Jasuja, Guneet K, Hogan, Timothy P, Lopez, Jaifred Christian F, Henderson, Blake, Fitzgerald, Blaine A, Goetschius, Amber, Hagan, Danielle, McCoy, Carl, Seelig, Alex, Nevedal, Andrea
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Switzerland Frontiers Media S.A 13-02-2024
• Subjects: Health Services; implementation science; innovation; program evaluation; RE-AIM; Veterans; innovation; RE-AIM; Veterans; program evaluation; implementation science
• ISSN: 2813-0146; 2813-0146
• DOI: 10.3389/frhs.2023.1223277

The Veterans Health Administration (VHA) Diffusion of Excellence (DoE) program provides a system to identify, replicate, and spread promising practices across the largest integrated healthcare system in the United States. DoE identifies innovations that have been successfully implemented in the VHA through a Shark Tank style competition. VHA facility and regional directors bid resources needed to replicate promising practices. Winning facilities/regions receive external facilitation to aid in replication/implementation over the course of a year. DoE staff then support diffusion of successful practices across the nationwide VHA.
Organized around the Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, and Maintenance (RE-AIM) Framework, we summarize results of an ongoing long-term mixed-methods implementation evaluation of DoE. Data sources include: Shark Tank application and bid details, tracking practice adoptions through a Diffusion Marketplace, characteristics of VHA facilities, focus groups with Shark Tank bidders, structured observations of DoE events, surveys of DoE program participants, and semi-structured interviews of national VHA program office leaders, VHA healthcare system/facility executives, practice developers, implementation teams and facilitators.
In the first eight Shark Tanks (2016-2022), 3,280 Shark Tank applications were submitted; 88 were designated DoE Promising Practices (i.e., practices receive facilitated replication). DoE has effectively spread practices across the VHA, with 1,440 documented instances of adoption/replication of practices across the VHA. This includes 180 adoptions/replications in facilities located in rural areas. Leadership decisions to adopt innovations are often based on big picture considerations such as constituency support and linkage to organizational goals. DoE Promising Practices that have the greatest national spread have been successfully replicated at new sites during the facilitated replication process, have close partnerships with VHA national program offices, and tend to be less expensive to implement. Two indicators of sustainment indicate that 56 of the 88 Promising Practices are still being diffused across the VHA; 56% of facilities originally replicating the practices have sustained them, even up to 6 years after the first Shark Tank.
DoE has developed a sustainable process for the identification, replication, and spread of promising practices as part of a learning health system committed to providing equitable access to high quality care.