Strength Is Still a Weakness in Coalition Formation: Replicating and Understanding the Strength-Is-Weakness Effect

• Published in: Personality & social psychology bulletin Vol. 48; no. 2; pp. 283 - 296
• Main Authors: Wissink, Joeri, van Beest, Ilja, Pronk, Tila, van de Ven, Niels
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Los Angeles, CA SAGE Publications 01-02-2022; SAGE PUBLICATIONS, INC
• Subjects: Coalition formation; Directing; Psychology; Strength; replication; online synchronous games; Strength-is-Weakness; coalition formation; equity
• ISSN: 0146-1672; 1552-7433
• DOI: 10.1177/01461672211005883

A key observation in coalition formation is that bargainers with most resources are often excluded from coalitions: the Strength-is-Weakness effect. Previous studies have suffered from low sample sizes and lack of (appropriate) incentives and have rarely focused on underlying processes. To address these issues, we conducted a cross-platform replication using the Online Coalition Game. We replicated the Strength-is-Weakness effect in a psychology laboratory, on Amazon Mechanical Turk, and on Prolific. Moreover, our results showed that the equity norm shapes the Strength-is-Weakness effect in two ways. First, strong bargainers claim a higher larger of the payoffs than weak bargainers do, making them less attractive coalition partners. Second, weak bargainers expect strong bargainers to make these larger claims, directing weak bargainers to each other from the outset. Finally, the studies suggest that the Online Coalition Game is a viable tool for conducting high-powered coalition formation research.