Comparative nutrient extraction from forages by grazing bovids and equids: a test of the nutritional model of equid/bovid competition and coexistence

• Published in: Oecologia Vol. 84; no. 3; pp. 411 - 418
• Main Authors: Duncan, P, Foose, T.J, Gordon, I.J, Gakahu, C.G, Lloyd, M
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Berlin Springer-Verlag 01-10-1990; Springer
• Subjects: Alfalfa; Animal and plant ecology; Animal digestion; Animal feeding behavior; Animal, plant and microbial ecology; Animals; Autoecology; Biological and medical sciences; Bovidae; cattle; digestion; Equidae; Forage; Fundamental and applied biological sciences. Psychology; Grasses; grazing; Horses; Mammalia; nutrient content; Nutrients; nutrition; Rumen fermentation; Ruminants; Ungulates; Vertebrata; Nutrition; Ruminant animal; Digestive system; Large intestin; Africa; Rumen; Coexistence; Digestion; Vertebrata; Mammalia; Interspecific competition; Models; Artiodactyla; Ungulata; Competition; Hind-gut fermenter; Intake; Ruminant
• ISSN: 0029-8549; 1432-1939
• DOI: 10.1007/bf00329768

Ruminants are unevenly distributed across the range of body sizes observed in herbivorous mammals; among extant East African species they predominate, in numbers and species richness, in the medium body sizes (10-600 kg). The small and the large species are all hind-gut fermenters. Some medium-sized hind-gut fermenters, equid perissodactyls, coexist with the grazing ruminants, principally bovid artiodactyls, in grassland ecosystems. These patterns have been explained by two complementary models based on differences between the digestive physiology of ruminants and hind-gut fermenters. The Demment and Van Soest (1985) model accounts for the absence of ruminants among the small and large species, while the Bell/Janis/Foose model accounts both for the predominance of ruminants, and their co-existence with equids among the medium-sized species (Bell 1971; Janis 1976; Foose 1982). The latter model assumes that the rumen is competitively superior to the hind-gut system on medium quality forages, and that hind-gut fermenters persist because of their ability to eat more, and thus to extract more nutrients per day from high fibre, low quality forages. Data presented here demonstrate that compared to similarly sized grazing ruminants (bovids), hind-gut fermenters (equids) have higher rates of food intake which more than compensate for their lesser ability to digest plant material. As a consequence equids extract more nutrients per day than bovids not only from low quality foods, but from the whole range of forages eaten by animals of this size. Neither of the current nutritional models, nor refinements of them satisfactorily explain the preponderance of the bovids among medium-sized ungulates; alternative hypotheses are presented.