The Multispecies Coalescent Over-Splits Species in the Case of Geographically Widespread Taxa

• Published in: Systematic biology Vol. 69; no. 1; pp. 184 - 193
• Main Authors: Chambers, E. Anne, Hillis, David M.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Oxford University Press 01-01-2020
• Subjects: Animals; Classification - methods; Phylogeny; Phylogeography; Points of View; Snakes - classification; Snakes - genetics; species delimitation; species concepts; taxonomy; Classification; speciation
• ISSN: 1063-5157; 1076-836X
• DOI: 10.1093/sysbio/syz042

Many recent species delimitation studies rely exclusively on limited analyses of genetic data analyzed under the multispecies coalescent (MSC) model, and results from these studies often are regarded as conclusive support for taxonomic changes. However, most MSC-based species delimitation methods have well-known and often unmet assumptions. Uncritical application of these genetic-based approaches (without due consideration of sampling design, the effects of a priori group designations, isolation by distance, cytoplasmic–nuclear mismatch, and population structure) can lead to over-splitting of species. Here, we argue that in many common biological scenarios, researchers must be particularly cautious regarding these limitations, especially in cases of well-studied, geographically variable, and parapatrically distributed species complexes. We consider these points with respect to a historically controversial species group, the American milksnakes (Lampropeltis triangulum complex), using genetic data from a recent analysis (Ruane et al. 2014). We show that over-reliance on the program Bayesian Phylogenetics and Phylogeography, without adequate consideration of its assumptions and of sampling limitations, resulted in over-splitting of species in this study. Several of the hypothesized species of milksnakes instead appear to represent arbitrary slices of continuous geographic clines. We conclude that the best available evidence supports three, rather than seven, species within this complex. More generally, we recommend that coalescent-based species delimitation studies incorporate thorough analyses of geographic variation and carefully examine putative contact zones among delimited species before making taxonomic changes.