Every step you take, we’ll be watching you: nudging and the ramifications of GPS technology

• Published in: AI & society Vol. 36; no. 3; pp. 863 - 875
• Main Authors: Hebblewhite, William, Gillett, Alexander James
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London Springer London 01-09-2021; Springer; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Artificial Intelligence; Cognition; Computer Science; Control; Decision making; Engineering Economics; Experimental research; Geographic information systems; Logistics; Marketing; Mechatronics; Methodology of the Social Sciences; Navigation behavior; Open Forum; Organization; Performing Arts; Robotics; Decision-making; Wayfinding technology; Navigation; Spatial cognition; Nudging; GPS devices; Enculturation; Autonomy; Geographic information systems
• ISSN: 0951-5666; 1435-5655
• DOI: 10.1007/s00146-020-01098-5

The increasing use of geographic information systems (GIS) in everyday life is profoundly shaping how humans navigate and interact with their surroundings. Behavioural and ethnographic experimental research indicates that increased usage of GPS devices is having a significant impact on human neurocognitive systems, especially memory and perception (Gramann et al. 2017). Despite this, there has only been a limited investigation of the implications of the spread of GIS technologies. In this paper, we explore how habitual reliance on GPS technology undermines autonomous decision-making through “nudging” (Sunstein and Thaler 2008)—that is, the alteration of psychological behaviour without the explicit forbidding of choice. In particular, we make a novel distinction between what we refer to as “suggestive nudging”—the suggesting of certain routes to take to get to a destination—and “disclosure nudging”—the normalisation of constant tracking and disclosing of our locations to government and corporate actors. We shall argue that although suggestive and disclosure nudging are
in principle
separate, that
in practice
they are intertwined in the design of modern GPS devices. Additionally, since human spatial cognition is highly plastic and susceptible to being sculpted by cultural practices (Hutchins 1995; Levinson 2003), this exacerbates the negative implications of the ‘in practice’ link of suggestive and disclosure nudging by making the latter harder to avoid and opt-out of. We argue that this state of affairs necessitates re-designing GPS devices.