Carbonates and intermediate-depth seismicity: Stable and unstable shear in altered subducting plates and overlying mantle

• Published in: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences - PNAS Vol. 120; no. 21; p. e2219076120
• Main Authors: Prakash, Abhishek, Holyoke, 3rd, Caleb W, Kelemen, Peter B, Kirby, Stephen H, Kronenberg, Andreas K, Lamb, William M
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States National Academy of Sciences 23-05-2023
• Subjects: Carbon dioxide; Carbonates; Carbonation; Dehydration; Earthquakes; Embrittlement; Heating; Kelvin-Helmholtz instability; Lava; Localization; Olivine; Physical Sciences; Plates; Seawater; Seismic activity; Seismic stability; Seismicity; Serpentine; Shear localization; Shear zone; Silicates; Slabs; Subduction (geology); Thin films; double Wadati–Benioff zones; intermediate-depth earthquakes; magnesite in mantle; thermal shear instability; carbonates
• ISSN: 0027-8424; 1091-6490
• DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2219076120

A model for intermediate-depth earthquakes of subduction zones is evaluated based on shear localization, shear heating, and runaway creep within thin carbonate layers in an altered downgoing oceanic plate and the overlying mantle wedge. Thermal shear instabilities in carbonate lenses add to potential mechanisms for intermediate-depth seismicity, which are based on serpentine dehydration and embrittlement of altered slabs or viscous shear instabilities in narrow fine-grained olivine shear zones. Peridotites in subducting plates and the overlying mantle wedge may be altered by reactions with CO
-bearing fluids sourced from seawater or the deep mantle, to form carbonate minerals, in addition to hydrous silicates. Effective viscosities of magnesian carbonates are higher than those for antigorite serpentine and they are markedly lower than those for H
O-saturated olivine. However, magnesian carbonates may extend to greater mantle depths than hydrous silicates at temperatures and pressures of subduction zones. Strain rates within altered downgoing mantle peridotites may be localized within carbonated layers following slab dehydration. A simple model of shear heating and temperature-sensitive creep of carbonate horizons, based on experimentally determined creep laws, predicts conditions of stable and unstable shear with strain rates up to 10/s, comparable to seismic velocities of frictional fault surfaces. Applied to intermediate-depth earthquakes of the Tonga subduction zone and the double Wadati-Benioff zone of NE Japan, this mechanism provides an alternative to the generation of earthquakes by dehydration embrittlement, beyond the stability of antigorite serpentine in subduction zones.