Species differences in bile acids I. Plasma and urine bile acid composition

• Published in: Journal of applied toxicology Vol. 38; no. 10; pp. 1323 - 1335
• Main Authors: Thakare, Rhishikesh, Alamoudi, Jawaher Abdullah, Gautam, Nagsen, Rodrigues, A. David, Alnouti, Yazen
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Wiley Subscription Services, Inc 01-10-2018
• Subjects: Acids; Animal models; Bile; Bile acids; Composition; Conjugation; Drug induced liver injury; Glutathione; Glycine; Homeostasis; Human, Preclinical species; Hydrophobicity; LC–MS/MS; Liver; Metabolites; Mice; Monkeys; Plasma; Species; Sulfation; Taurine; Toxicity; Urine; Urine; Drug induced liver injury; LC-MS/MS; Plasma; Bile acids; Human, Preclinical species
• ISSN: 0260-437X; 1099-1263
• DOI: 10.1002/jat.3644

Maintenance of bile acid (BA) homeostasis is essential to achieve their physiologic functions and avoid their toxic effects. The marked differences in BA composition between preclinical safety models and humans may play a major role in the poor prediction of drug‐induced liver injury using preclinical models. We compared the composition of plasma and urinary BAs and their metabolites between humans and several animal species. Total BA pools and their composition varied widely among different species. Highest sulfation of BAs was observed in human and chimpanzee. Glycine amidation was predominant in human, minipig, hamster and rabbit, while taurine amidation was predominant in mice, rat and dogs. BA profiles consisted primarily of tri‐OH BAs in hamster, rat, dog and mice, di‐OH BAs in human, rabbit and minipig, and mono‐OH BA in chimpanzee. BA profiles comprised primarily hydrophilic and less toxic BAs in mice, rat, pig and hamster, while it primarily comprised hydrophobic and more toxic BAs in human, rabbit and chimpanzee. Therefore, the hydrophobicity index was lowest in minipig and mice, while it was highest in rabbit, monkey and human. Glucuronidation and glutathione conjugation were low in all species across all BAs. Total concentration of BAs in urine was up to 10× higher and more hydrophilic than plasma in most species. This was due to the presence of more tri‐OH, amidated, sulfated and primary BAs, in urine compared to plasma. In general, BA profiles of chimpanzee and monkeys were most similar to human, while minipig, rat and mice were most dissimilar to human.
The marked differences in bile acid (BA) composition between preclinical safety models and humans may play a major role in the poor prediction of drug‐induced liver injury. We compared the composition of plasma and urinary BAs and their metabolites between humans and several animal species. BA profiles varied widely among different species and it comprised primarily hydrophilic and less toxic BAs in mice, rat, pig and hamster, while it primarily comprised hydrophobic and more toxic BAs in human, rabbit and chimpanzee. In general, BA profiles of chimpanzee and monkeys were most similar to humans, while minipig, rat and mice were most dissimilar to humans.