Discontinuation versus continuation of hypertonic saline or dornase alfa in modulator treated people with cystic fibrosis (SIMPLIFY): results from two parallel, multicentre, open-label, randomised, controlled, non-inferiority trials

• Published in: The lancet respiratory medicine Vol. 11; no. 4; pp. 329 - 340
• Main Authors: Mayer-Hamblett, Nicole, Russell, Renee, Donaldson, Scott H, Sawicki, Gregory S, Odem-Davis, Katherine, Rosenbluth, Daniel, Taylor-Cousar, Jennifer L, Goss, Christopher H, Clancy, John Paul, O'Sullivan, Brian P, Berlinski, Ariel, Millard, Susan L, Omlor, Gregory, Wyatt, Colby A, Moffett, Kathryn, Kloster, Margaret, Chapdu, Claire, VanDalfsen, Jill, Mead, Anna, Seidel, Kathy, Couture, Laurel, Case, Brooke Zappone, Au, Wendy, Olander, Amber, VanHousen, Lisya, Parrish, Michelle, Head, Jillian, Carey, Jessica, Lysinger, Jerimiah, Virella-Lowell, Isabel, Brown, Perry, Godusevic, Lejla, Sweet, Julie, Donaldson, Scott, Szentpetery, Sylvia, Tharrington, Erica, Jain, Manu, McPhail, Gary, McBennett, Kimberly, Weaver, Dave, Sharma, Preeti, Jones, Amy, Cross, Mary, Mukadam, Zubin, Finto, Jill, Schultz, Karen, Graff, Gavin, Thompson, Misty, Teresi, Mary, Schaeffer, David, Mermis, Joel, Scott, Lawrence, Escobar, Hugo, O'Sullivan, Brian, Danov, Zoran, Turbeville, Kat, Marra, Bridget, Morton, Ronald, Dondlinger, Nicole, Biller, Julie, Billings, Joanne, Balaji, Priya, Griffith, Rebecca, Martinez, Nancy, Hussain, Sabiha, Guzman, Catalina, DeCelie-Germana, Joan, Galvin, Susan, Falgout, Nicole, Demarco, Teresa, DiMango, Emily, Ycaza, Maria, Tirakitsoontorn, Pornchai, Layish, Daniel, Wooldridge, Sherry, Milla, Carlos, Spano, Jacquelyn, Elidemir, Okan, Scott, Ashley, Alam, Sarah, Dorgan, Daniel, Weiner, Daniel, Renna, Harmony, Wyatt, Colby, Stone, Anne, Liou, Theodore, Akong, Kathryn, Gil, Marissa, Singer, Jonathan, Moreno, Courtney, Gambol, Teresa, Milton, Joan, Hodge, Diana, Fortner, Christopher, Forell, Mary, Patel, Kapil, Daines, Cori, Ryan, Elizabeth, Powell, Kay, Polineni, Deepika
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Elsevier Ltd 01-04-2023
• Subjects: Cystic Fibrosis - drug therapy; Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane Conductance Regulator; Deoxyribonuclease I - adverse effects; Humans; Lung; Saline Solution, Hypertonic
• ISSN: 2213-2600; 2213-2619; 2213-2619
• DOI: 10.1016/S2213-2600(22)00434-9

Reducing treatment burden is a priority for people with cystic fibrosis, whose health has benefited from using new modulators that substantially increase CFTR protein function. The SIMPLIFY study aimed to assess the effects of discontinuing nebulised hypertonic saline or dornase alfa in individuals using the CFTR modulator elexacaftor plus tezacaftor plus ivacaftor (ETI).
The SIMPLIFY study included two parallel, multicentre, open-label, randomised, controlled, non-inferiority trials at 80 participating clinics across the USA in the Cystic Fibrosis Therapeutics Development Network. We included individuals with cystic fibrosis aged 12–17 years with percent predicted FEV1 (ppFEV1) of 70% or more, or those aged 18 years or older with ppFEV1 of 60% or more, if they had been taking ETI and either (or both) mucoactive therapies (≥3% hypertonic saline or dornase alfa) for at least 90 days before screening. Participants on both hypertonic saline and dornase alfa were randomly assigned to one of the two trials, and those on a single therapy were assigned to the applicable trial. All participants were then randomly assigned 1:1 to continue or discontinue therapy for 6 weeks using permuted blocks of varying size, stratified by baseline ppFEV1 (week 0; ≥90% or <90%), single or concurrent use of hypertonic saline and dornase alfa, previous SIMPLIFY study participation (yes or no), and age (≥18 or <18 years). For participants randomly assigned to continue their therapy during a given trial, this therapy was instructed to be taken at least once daily according to each participant's pre-existing, clinically prescribed regimen. Hypertonic saline concentration was required to be at least 3%. The primary objective for each trial was to determine whether discontinuing was non-inferior to continuing, measured by the 6-week change in ppFEV1 in the per-protocol population. We established a non-inferiority margin of –3% for the difference between groups in the 6-week change in ppFEV1. Safety outcomes were analysed in the intention-to-treat population. This study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT04378153.
From Aug 25, 2020, to May 25, 2022, a total of 672 unique participants were screened for eligibility for one or both trials, resulting in 847 total random assignments across both trials with 594 unique participants. 370 participants were randomly assigned in the hypertonic saline trial and 477 in the dornase alfa trial. Participants across both trials had an average ppFEV1 of 96·9%. Discontinuing treatment was non-inferior to continuing treatment with respect to the absolute 6-week change in ppFEV1 in both the hypertonic saline trial (–0·19% [95% CI –0·85 to 0·48] in the discontinuation group [n=133] vs 0·14% [–0·51 to 0·78] in the continuation group [n=140]; between-group difference –0·32% [–1·25 to 0·60]) and dornase alfa trial (0·18% [–0·38 to 0·74] in the discontinuation group [n=199] vs –0·16% [–0·73 to 0·41] in the continuation group [n=193]; between-group difference 0·35% [–0·45 to 1·14]), with consistent results in the intention-to-treat populations. In the hypertonic saline trial, 64 (35%) of 184 in the discontinuation group versus 44 (24%) of 186 participants in the continuation group and, in the dornase alfa trial, 89 (37%) of 240 in the discontinuation group versus 55 (23%) of 237 in the continuation group had at least one adverse event.
In individuals with cystic fibrosis on ETI with relatively well preserved pulmonary function, discontinuing daily hypertonic saline or dornase alfa for 6 weeks did not result in clinically meaningful differences in pulmonary function when compared with continuing treatment.