Effect of changing journal clubs from traditional method to evidence-based method on psychiatry residents

• Published in: Advances in medical education and practice Vol. 7; pp. 483 - 487
• Main Authors: Faridhosseini, Farhad, Saghebi, Ali, Khadem-Rezaiyan, Majid, Moharari, Fatemeh, Dadgarmoghaddam, Maliheh
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: New Zealand Dove Medical Press Limited 2016; Taylor & Francis Ltd; Dove Medical Press
• Subjects: Behavioral sciences; Clubs; Critical care; Curricula; Design; Evidence-based practice; Medical education; Medical societies; Medicine; Membership; Methods; Original Research; Psychiatry; Social aspects; Studies; Teaching; residents; journal club; education method; evidence-based
• ISSN: 1179-7258; 1179-7258
• DOI: 10.2147/AMEP.S110036

Journal club is a valuable educational tool in the medical field. This method follows different goals. This study aims to investigate the effect on psychiatry residents of changing journal clubs from the traditional method to the evidence-based method.
This study was conducted using a before-after design. First- and second-year residents of psychiatry were included in the study. First, the status quo was evaluated by standardized questionnaire regarding the effect of journal club. Then, ten sessions were held to familiarize the residents with the concept of journal club. After that, evidence-based journal club sessions were held. The questionnaire was given to the residents again after the final session. Data were analyzed through descriptive statistics (frequency and percentage frequency, mean and standard deviation), and analytic statistics (paired t-test) using SPSS 22.
Of a total of 20 first- and second-year residents of psychiatry, the data of 18 residents were finally analyzed. Most of the subjects (17 [93.7%]) were females. The mean overall score before and after the intervention was 1.83±0.45 and 2.85±0.57, respectively, which showed a significant increase (P<0.001).
Moving toward evidence-based journal clubs seems like an appropriate measure to reach the goals set by this educational tool.