Breast restoration decision making: Enhancing the process

• Published in: Cancer nursing Vol. 21; no. 3; pp. 196 - 204
• Main Author: Reaby, Linda L
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Lippincott-Raven Publishers 01-06-1998
• Subjects: Adult; Aged; Breast Implantation - psychology; Breast Neoplasms - nursing; Breast Neoplasms - psychology; Breast Neoplasms - rehabilitation; Female; Humans; Mastectomy - psychology; Mastectomy - rehabilitation; Middle Aged; Models, Psychological; Nursing; Nursing Evaluation Research; Patient Advocacy; Prostheses and Implants
• ISSN: 0162-220X; 1538-9804
• DOI: 10.1097/00002820-199806000-00007

The purpose of this study was to explore the breast restoration decision-making patterns used by women who opted to have their breast cancer treated by mastectomy. Sixty-four women wearing external breast prostheses and 31 women with breast reconstructions were interviewed. Modified versions of Simon's notion of "bounded rationality" and Janis and Mann's conflict model provided the conceptual scaffolding for the study. Five breast restoration decision-making patterns emerged from the analysis of the interview data(a) Enlightened (actively seeks information, considers positive and negative aspects, and demonstrates deliberation on the alternatives), (b) Contented (passively accepts minimum information on alternatives because of a preference toward a particular type), (c) Sideliner (uncritically adopts any alternative that is easy and simple to implement), (d) Shifter (gives over the decision to others), and (e) Panic-stricken (can make no rational decision on alternatives). In the prosthesis group, the major pattern used was the Sideliner, and in the reconstruction group it was the Contented. None of the participants used the Enlightened pattern. The data indicated that there was no evidence of active information-seeking behavior or deliberation on the alternatives as part of the women's decision-making process. The findings suggest a need for a registered nurse oncology specialist to be accessible to women during the period when decisions regarding breast restoration are made. This professional has the knowledge to interact effectively with these women and serve as their advocate during the decision-making process. Implications for professional practice and a model for competent breast restoration decision making are presented.