Ideology or economics: government banking in New Zealand

• Published in: Journal of management history (2006) Vol. 17; no. 3; pp. 299 - 314
• Main Authors: Cardow, Andrew, Tripe, David, Wilson, William
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Emerald Group Publishing Limited 01-01-2011
• Subjects: New Zealand; Politics; Privatization; Nationalization; Banking; Socialist economies
• ISSN: 1751-1348; 1758-7751
• DOI: 10.1108/17511341111141378

Purpose - This paper aims to argue that in the short history of New Zealand banking, political experimentation, based at first upon socialist ideology of the 1940s led to the nationalisation of The Bank of New Zealand (BNZ), followed by a period of neo-liberalism in the 1980s and early 1990s in which the bank was privatised. It further argues that the establishment of Kiwibank Ltd in New Zealand at the dawn of the twenty-first century was a return to the political ideology of the 1940s.Design methodology approach - The paper discusses the nationalisation and subsequent privatisation of the BNZ and draws a parallel between the perceived banking environment as it existed in New Zealand in the twentieth century and as it existed at the establishment of Kiwibank. By way of context setting it also discusses the political environment as it relates to the nationalisation of the Bank of England.Findings - The paper finds that in New Zealand, political experimentation, not commercial pragmatism, was the underlying motivating factor for the state's involvement in banking.Originality value - The paper contributes to the pool of knowledge regarding the political motivations behind nationalisation and state ownership of banking assets. The article is of interest to economic and political historians as well as those who study New Zealand political party history. Future policy makers could do well to reflect upon the motivations for state ownership of banking assets by asking if their decisions are driven by ideology or economics.