Multiple Faces of Personality Domains: Revalidating the Proposed Domains

• Published in: Psychiatria Danubina Vol. 31; no. 2; pp. 182 - 188
• Main Authors: Pesic, Danilo, Lecic-Tosevski, Dusica, Kalanj, Marko, Vukovic, Olivera, Mitkovic-Voncina, Marija, Peljto, Amir, Mulder, Roger
• Format: Journal Article Paper
• Language: English
• Published: Croatia Medicinska naklada 01-06-2019
• Subjects: borderline; factor analysis; ICD-11 proposed domains; personality disorders; personality pathology domain
• ISSN: 0353-5053; 1849-0867
• DOI: 10.24869/psyd.2019.182

Despite relatively consistent findings regarding the number of personality pathology domains, differences in domain structure remain. Recently the proposed ICD-11 domains were partially validated in a sample of patients with major depression producing five domains: Detached, Anankastic, Negative Emotional, Antisocial and Borderline. The aim of our study was to attempt to cross-validate these findings in a sample of patients primarily diagnosed with personality disorder (PD).
All subjects were assessed by Structured Clinical Interview for the DSM-IV Axis II PD. Exploratory factor analysis (EFA) was applied on fifty seven DSM PD symptoms selected to represent the five proposed domains.
SCID II data were collected from a total of 223 subjects. The EFA extracted five factors. The first factor labeled as borderline-internalizing constituted of borderline together with avoidant and dependent items, the second, labeled as disinhibited/ borderline externalizing, incorporated narcissistic and histrionic items. The other three separate factors in our study labeled as antisocial, anankastic and detached, were less robust.
In our study five personality pathology domains were partly replicated. The most robust findings support the existence of the two factors, borderline-internalizing and disinhibited/borderline externalizing. However, the EFA was performed on a relatively low prevalence symptoms distribution, particularly for antisocial and schizoid factors.