The Pentland Firth and Orkney Waters and Scotland – Planning Europe's Atlantic gateway

• Published in: Marine policy Vol. 71; pp. 285 - 292
• Main Authors: Johnson, Kate R., Kerr, Sandy A., Side, Jonathan C.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier Ltd 01-09-2016
• Subjects: Accommodation; Brackish; Community planning; Community relations; Integration land/marine planning; Marine; Marine environments; Marine renewable energy; Marine rights; Marine spatial planning; Pilots; Policies; Regional planning; Scotland; Zoning; ANE, British Isles, Scotland, Highland, Caithness, Pentland Firth; ANE, Europe; ANE, British Isles, Scotland, Orkney; A, Atlantic; ANE, British Isles, Scotland; Marine rights; Scotland; Marine spatial planning; Marine renewable energy; Integration land/marine planning
• ISSN: 0308-597X; 1872-9460
• DOI: 10.1016/j.marpol.2015.12.006

The non-statutory pilot regional marine spatial plan for the Pentland Firth and Orkney Waters (PFOW) is a test to establish a precedent for the whole of Scotland. It is a pilot because it precedes and tests implementation of the statutory process for marine planning set out in the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010. It was selected by the government for the pilot because of the high level of existing and proposed marine renewable energy (MRE) development in a relatively pristine area of coastal waters where traditional activities and habitats protection are already important. The PFOW is the first designated ‘Marine Energy Park’ in Scotland. It is under immediate pressure of development and the PFOW plan is already in use in support of the development consenting regime. This case study of the emerging plan identifies issues of generic importance to the planning of marine areas under development pressure in near shore locations. In particular, it highlights issues affecting the relationship between marine and terrestrial planning and the interests of adjacent island and coastal communities. The study concludes that a strong central marine governance regime is developing but that engagement of the local community and accommodation of terrestrial planning interests require further consideration. Full integration between marine and land planning may be unattainable but an equitable working relationship between them is essential. A notable feature of the PFOW plan is rejection of zoning in favour of a more pragmatic approach based on consenting criteria and locational guidance.
•Planning pristine marine areas under development pressure from marine renewables.•Integration of land and marine planning maybe unattainable, equitable link essential.•Action to resolve built-in conflicts among existing marine rights is a priority.•Programme of social science research needed to account for community interests.•Scenarios for progression from the marine planning experiment in Scotland.