Factors that affect consent rate for organ donation after brain death: A 12-year registry

• Published in: Journal of the neurological sciences Vol. 416; p. 117036
• Main Authors: Kananeh, Mohammed F., Brady, Paul D., Mehta, Chandan B., Louchart, Lisa P., Rehman, Mohammed F., Schultz, Lonni R., Lewis, Ariane, Varelas, Panayiotis N.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Netherlands Elsevier B.V 15-09-2020
• Subjects: Apnea; Approach; Brain Death; Consent; Family; Humans; Informed Consent; Middle Aged; Organ donation; Prospective Studies; Registries; Tissue and Organ Procurement; AA; BD; DI; GOL; Brain death; NICU; HFH; OPO; Organ donation; Apnea; Consent; Approach; ICU; AANPP
• ISSN: 0022-510X; 1878-5883
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jns.2020.117036

To account for factors affecting family approach and consent for organ donation after brain death (BD).
A prospective cohort study in a large, tertiary, urban hospital, where we reviewed the database of all brain-dead patients between January 2006 and December 2017 cross-matched with local organ procurement organization (OPO) records.
Two-hundred sixty-six brain-dead patients were included (55% African Americans (AAs)). Two-hundred twenty-two were approached for donation. The reason for not approaching families was medical exclusion due to cancer or multi-organ failure. Patient demographics or religion were not associated with approaching families. Lower creatinine level was the only independent factor associated with higher approach. Consent rate for organ donation was 72.5%. Consent was significantly higher in Caucasians (89% vs 62% for AAs), younger patients (46.7 vs 52.5 years old), in patients with lower creatinine at time of death (1.7 vs 2.4 mg/dL), patients for whom apnea testing was completed (92% vs 80%) and patients with diabetes insipidus (DI) (72% vs 54%). There was no significant relationship between consent and patient gender, admission diagnosis, number of examinations or completion of a confirmatory test. In a logistic regression model, only AA race independently predicted consent for donation (odds, 95% CI, 0.27, 0.12–0.57 p < .001). In a different model, apnea test completion was an additional independent predictor (3.66, 1.28–10.5 p = .015).
Approaching families for organ donation consent was associated with medical suitability only and not with demographic or religious characteristics. AAs were 3.7 times less likely to consent for organ donation than non-AAs. Completion of apnea testing was associated with higher consent rates, an observation that needs to be explored in future studies documenting the effect on bedside family presence during this test.
•Brain dead patients' race plays no role in approaching families for organ donation•Brain dead patients' religion plays no role approaching families for organ donation•African American race leads to 3.7 times lower consent for organ donation•Apnea test completion leads to 3.7 times higher consent for organ donation