Establishing consensus on the perioperative management of cholecystectomy in public hospitals: a Delphi study with an expert panel in Mexico

• Published in: HPB (Oxford, England) Vol. 23; no. 5; pp. 685 - 699
• Main Authors: Romero, Rey Jesus, Martinez-Mier, Gustavo, Ayala-García, Marco A., Beristain-Hernández, Jose Luis, Chan-Nuñez, Luis Carlos, Chapa-Azuela, Oscar, Dominguez-Rosado, Ismael, Flores-Villalba, Eduardo, Fuentes-Orozco, Clotilde, García-Covarrubias, Luis, González-Ojeda, Alejandro, Herrera-Hernández, Miguel Francisco, Martinez-Ordaz, José Luis, Medina-Franco, Heriberto, Mercado, Miguel Angel, Montalvo-Jave, Eduardo, Nuño-Guzmán, Carlos Martine, Torices-Escalante, Eduardo, Torres-Villalobos, Gonzalo Manuel, Vilatoba-Chapa, Mario, Zamora-Godinez, Jordán, Zapata-Chavira, Homero, Zerrweck-Lopez, Carlos
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Elsevier Ltd 01-05-2021
• Subjects: Cholecystectomy; Consensus; Delphi Technique; Hospitals, Public; Humans; Mexico; Mexico
• ISSN: 1365-182X; 1477-2574
• DOI: 10.1016/j.hpb.2020.09.021

Several guidelines have put forward recommendations about the perioperative process of cholecystectomy. Despite the recommendations, controversy remains concerning several topics, especially in low- and middle-income countries. The aim of this study was to develop uniform recommendations for perioperative practices in cholecystectomy in Mexico to standardize this process and save public health system resources.
A modified Delphi method was used. An expert panel of 23 surgeons anonymously completed two rounds of responses to a 29-item questionnaire with 110 possible answers. The consensus was assessed using the percentage of responders agreeing on each question.
From the 29 questions, the study generated 27 recommendations based on 20 (69.0%) questions reaching consensus, one that was considered uncertain (3.4%), and six (20.7%) items that remained open questions. In two (6.9%) cases, no consensus was reached, and no recommendation could be made.
This study provides recommendations for the perioperative management of cholecystectomy in public hospitals in Mexico. As a guide for public institutions in low- and middle-income countries, the study identifies recommendations for perioperative tests and evaluations, perioperative decision making, postoperative interventions and institutional investment, that might ensure the safe practice of cholecystectomy and contribute to conserving resources.