Foreign interests and state repression: Theory and evidence from the Armenian genocide

• Published in: Journal of peace research Vol. 60; no. 2; pp. 307 - 321
• Main Author: Lehmann, M Christian
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London, England SAGE Publications 01-03-2023; Sage Publications Ltd
• Subjects: Campaigns; Deportation; Genocide; Inequality; Loyalty; Massacres; Military intervention; Oppression; Perpetrators; Poverty; Provinces; Repression (Defense mechanism); German empire; Ottoman empire; rationalist theory; political violence
• ISSN: 0022-3433; 1460-3578
• DOI: 10.1177/00223433211068304

Existing work seeks explanations for state repression mainly in domestic factors such as ethnic/religious cleavages, poverty and inequality, struggle for power, regime type and quality of state institutions, lack of loyalty, demand for scapegoats, and cultural or psychological traits of perpetrators. How foreign influences shape state repression has been given less attention. Furthermore, the focus of the empirical literature has been largely cross-country, leaving much local variation unexplained. In this article, I examine how far foreign interests can explain the local (spatial) variation of deportations and massacres during the Armenian genocide. Between 1915 and 1917 the Ottoman Empire carried out a massive campaign of state repression (deportations and massacres) against its Armenian population. There was meaningful variation across Ottoman provinces in the intensity of this campaign, that is, some provinces experienced more repression than others. I investigate the determinants of this spatial variation. My empirical analysis is guided by a rationalist (economic) model where deportation is a tool to stifle Armenian calls for independence, but the benefit and cost of deportation vary spatially. For example, deportation is costlier (i.e. the risk of foreign intervention is greater) in locations where foreign economic and military interests are threatened by the departure of Armenians. In line with the model’s predictions, my empirical analysis indicates that there were fewer deportations in places where Armenians worked for the German-owned railway.