Using a participatory qualitative risk assessment to estimate the risk of introduction and spread of transboundary animal diseases in scarce-data environments: A Spatial Qualitative Risk Analysis applied to foot-and-mouth disease in Tunisia 2014-2019

• Published in: Transboundary and emerging diseases Vol. 68; no. 4; pp. 1966 - 1978
• Main Authors: Squarzoni-Diaw, Cécile, Arsevska, Elena, Kalthoum, Sana, Hammami, Pachka, Cherni, Jamel, Daoudi, Assia, Karim Laoufi, Mohamed, Lezaar, Yassir, Rachid, Kechna, Seck, Ismaila, Ould Elmamy, Bezeid, Yahya, Barry, Dufour, Barbara, Hendrikx, Pascal, Cardinale, Eric, Muñoz, Facundo, Lancelot, Renaud, Coste, Caroline
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Germany Hindawi Limited 01-07-2021
• Subjects: Animal diseases; Animal health; Borders; Categories; Decision support systems; Disease; Disease control; Epidemiology; Foot & mouth disease; Iterative methods; Outbreaks; Qualitative analysis; Regional development; Risk analysis; Risk assessment; Risk factors; Risk levels; Spatial variations; Workshops; Tunisia; risk assessment; animal movements; transboundary animal diseases; risk mapping
• ISSN: 1865-1674; 1865-1682
• DOI: 10.1111/tbed.13920

This article presents a participative and iterative qualitative risk assessment framework that can be used to evaluate the spatial variation of the risk of infectious animal disease introduction and spread on a national scale. The framework was developed through regional training action workshops and field activities. The active involvement of national animal health services enabled the identification, collection and hierarchization of risk factors. Quantitative data were collected in the field, and expert knowledge was integrated to adjust the available data at regional level. Experts categorized and combined the risk factors into ordinal levels of risk per epidemiological unit to ease implementation of risk-based surveillance in the field. The framework was used to perform a qualitative assessment of the risk of introduction and spread of foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) in Tunisia as part of a series of workshops held between 2015 and 2018. The experts in attendance combined risk factors such as epidemiological status, transboundary movements, proximity to the borders and accessibility to assess the risk of FMD outbreaks in Tunisia. Out of the 2,075 Tunisian imadas, 23 were at a very high risk of FMD introduction, mainly at the borders; and 59 were at a very high risk of FMD spread. To validate the model, the results were compared to the FMD outbreaks notified by Tunisia during the 2014 FMD epizootic. Using a spatial Poisson model, a significant alignment between the very high and high-risk categories of spread and the occurrence of FMD outbreaks was shown. The relative risk of FMD occurrence was thus 3.2 higher for imadas in the very high and high spread risk categories than for imadas in the low and negligible spread risk categories. Our results show that the qualitative risk assessment framework can be a useful decision support tool for risk-based disease surveillance and control, in particular in scarce-data environments.