The space of encounter and the making of difference: The entangled lives of Alevi and Sunni neighbours in Turkey

• Published in: Transactions - Institute of British Geographers (1965) Vol. 48; no. 2; pp. 380 - 394
• Main Authors: Gökarıksel, Banu, Secor, Anna J.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London Wiley Subscription Services, Inc 01-06-2023
• Subjects: Alevis; difference; encounter; Feminist criticism; feminist political geography; Inequality; Neighborhoods; neighbours; Power; Proximity; Public spaces; Sunni Muslims; Thresholds; Tolerance; Turkey; Turkey
• ISSN: 0020-2754; 1475-5661
• DOI: 10.1111/tran.12584

The concept of encounter has long been central to a cosmopolitan ethos in which coming together in urban public space is expected to yield tolerance and pluralism. More recently scholars have reworked this concept to account for not only what is potentially transformative in encounters but also how encounters are conditioned by and productive of relations of power and inequality. Our study contributes to this reworking, and to feminist critiques of space and politics, by centring the spatiality of encounter in the entanglement of neighbours. Drawing on our focus group research (2013–2016) with Alevis and Sunnis in Istanbul and Malatya, we argue that difficult questions of difference, responsibility, and power come to the fore in neighbour relations. While our study underlines how Sunni supremacism and Alevi precarity are constituted in the everyday lives of neighbours, we also find that there is a transformational potential in these encounters that is not fully (re)absorbed into structures of Alevi–Sunni difference. We argue that, across the blurry boundaries of home and neighbourhood spaces, the unbidden intimacies of living in proximity (the drift of smells and sounds, the lines of sight that connect balconies and windows, the presence of neighbours at the thresholds and in the spaces of each other's homes) mean that encounters between neighbours both fuel and trouble the marking out of what is shared and what is separate, what is tolerable and what crosses a line. Our study thereby advances an understanding of the space of encounter, the making of difference, and the political and ethical significance of this entanglement.
Short
Our study advances an understanding of the space of encounter, the making of difference, and the political and ethical significance of this entanglement. Drawing on our focus group research (2013–2016) with Alevis and Sunnis in Istanbul and Malatya, we argue that questions of difference, responsibility, and power come to the fore in encounters between neighbours. While our study underlines how Sunni supremacism and Alevi precarity are constituted in the everyday lives of neighbours, we also find that there is a transformational potential in these encounters that is not fully absorbed into structures of Alevi‐Sunni difference.