Critical theory and praxis in post-apartheid South Africa: the case for a critical criminology

• Published in: Acta academica (Bloemfontein, South Africa) Vol. 52; no. 2; pp. 106 - 130
• Main Author: Lötter, Casper
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: University of the Free State 01-12-2020
• Subjects: Conflict criminology; Critical theory; Frankfurt School; Humanities, Multidisciplinary; Marxist-inspired criminology; Political Science; prison-industrial complex; Social context; Social Issues; Structural oppression; conflict criminology; Marxist-inspired criminology; Critical Theory; prison-industrial complex; structural oppression; Frankfurt School; social context
• ISSN: 0587-2405; 2415-0479; 2415-0479
• DOI: 10.18820/24150479/aa52i2/6

The obsession with empirical work in South African criminology has led to a neglect of ‘context’ in the form of skimming over structural oppressions, such as racism, inequality, poverty and unemployment, as if they were not potently criminogenic societal factors. With regard to analysing so-called conventional crime, the aforementioned ‘context’ is an extremely important consideration in a country teeming with these structural oppressions. Contributions from both Critical Theory and Marxist-inspired criminology could correct this imbalance. Following the backdrop of such a discussion, this paper will examine the phenomenon of the prison industrial complex, both in the US and, more particularly, in the local setting. The argument will then conclude with a three-pronged assessment, namely 1) an evaluation of the debt which Marxist-inspired criminologists (Jeffery Reiman, Angela Davis and Richard Quinney) owe to the Frankfurt School, 2) an overview of the relevant ideas from Critical Theory, and, 3) the application of conflict criminology supplemented by scholarly work in the tradition of the Frankfurt School (represented by Habermas and Žižek) to South African conditions.