Examination Scores but not Clinical Performance Correlate With Duration of Preclinical Didactic Time: A Synchronous Comparison of Second- Versus Third-Year Medical Students on the Surgery Clerkship

• Published in: Journal of surgical education Vol. 80; no. 7; pp. 957 - 964
• Main Authors: Huerta, Carlos Theodore, Cohen, Brianna L., Hernandez, Alexandra E., Saberi, Rebecca A., Thorson, Chad M., Hui, Vanessa W., Rodgers, Steven E., Sands, Laurence R.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Elsevier Inc 01-07-2023
• Subjects: Clinical Clerkship; Clinical Competence; Education, Medical, Undergraduate; Educational Measurement; Humans; medical education; NBME shelf; recorded lecture; Students, Medical; surgery clerkship; surgical education; Time Factors; recorded lecture; medical education; Medical Knowledge; Systems-Based Practice; Practice-Based Learning and Improvement; NBME shelf; surgical education; surgery clerkship
• ISSN: 1931-7204; 1878-7452
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2023.05.001

•Many medical schools have reduced preclinical time to initiate rotations earlier.•The effects of this trend on performance later in the surgery clerkship are unclear.•Second- and third-year student performance on the surgery clerkship was compared.•Third-years outperformed second-years on objective examination metrics.•Second- and third-years performed similarly on clinical metrics.
Numerous institutions have reduced preclinical didactic time to facilitate earlier clinical exposure during the second year of medical education. However, the effects that shortened preclinical education may have on performance in the surgery clerkship are unclear. This study aims to compare the clinical and examination performance of second- (MS2) and third-year (MS3) students synchronously completing an identical surgery clerkship.
All students completing the surgery clerkship (identical didactics, examinations, clinical rotations, etc.) were included. MS3s received 24 months of preclinical education, whereas MS2s received 14 months. Performance outcomes included weekly quizzes based on lectures, NBME Surgery Shelf Exam, numeric clinical evaluations, objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) scores, and overall clerkship grades.
University of Miami Miller School of Medicine.
All second- (MS2) and third-year (MS3) medical students completing the Surgery Clerkship over 1 year (n = 395).
There were 199 MS3 (50%) and 196 MS2 (50%) students. MS3s demonstrated higher median shelf exams (77% vs 72% MS2s), weekly quiz score averages (87% vs 80% MS2s), clinical evaluations (96% vs 95% MS2s), and overall clerkship grades (89% vs 87% MS2s), all p < 0.020. There was no difference in median OSCE performance (both 92%; p = 0.499). A greater proportion of MS3 students performed in the highest 50% of weekly quiz scores (57% vs 43% MS2), NBME shelf exams (59% vs 39% MS2), and overall clerkship grades (45% vs 37% MS2), all p < 0.010. No significant difference in the proportion of students placing in the top 50% of clinical parameters including the OSCE (48% MS3 vs 46% MS2; p = 0.106) and clinical evaluations (45% MS3 vs 38%; p = 0.185) was observed.
Although the duration of preclerkship education may correspond to examination scores, MS2s and MS3s perform similarly on clinical metrics. Future strategies to enhance available preclinical didactic time and preparation for examinations are needed.