Assessing the performance of the HARMONIE-AROME and WRF-ARW numerical models in North Atlantic Tropical Transitions

• Published in: Atmospheric research Vol. 291; p. 106801
• Main Authors: Calvo-Sancho, C., Quitián-Hernández, L., González-Alemán, J.J., Bolgiani, P., Santos-Muñoz, D., Martín, M.L.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier B.V 01-08-2023
• Subjects: HARMONIE-AROME; North Atlantic basin; Object-based verification; Tropical Transitions; WRF; Tropical Transitions; WRF; HARMONIE-AROME; Object-based verification; North Atlantic basin
• ISSN: 0169-8095; 1873-2895
• DOI: 10.1016/j.atmosres.2023.106801

Tropical cyclones (TCs) can develop as a result of the tropical transition (TT) process, which occurs when an extratropical cyclone (EC) begins to exhibit tropical characteristics, forming a TC. In this study, four TT processes that lead to a hurricane structure [Delta (2005), Ophelia (2017), Leslie (2018), and Theta (2020)] are evaluated using two high-resolution numerical models (WRF and HARMONIE-AROME). Both tracks and intensities of the cyclones are assessed by comparing the simulated minimum sea level pressure and maximum wind speed to an observational dataset. Moreover, a spatial verification is performed by comparing the MSG-SEVIRI brightness temperature (BT) and accumulated precipitation (IMERG) to the corresponding simulations accomplished by both models. Analyzing the track results, the WRF model, on average, outstands HARMONIE-AROME. However, it is the HARMONIE-AROME model that performs better than WRF when reproducing the intensity of these cyclones. Concerning the BT spatial validation, HARMONIE-AROME slightly outperformed WRF when reproducing the cyclone's structure but failed when simulating the BT amplitude. Besides, both models achieved a nearly perfect cyclone location. In terms of accumulated precipitation results, the HARMONIE-AROME model overestimates the larger structures while underestimating the smaller ones, whereas the WRF model underestimates the bigger structures, being poorly located by both models. Although it is difficult to establish which numerical model performs better, the overall results show an outstanding of the HARMONIE-AROME model over the WRF model when simulating TT processes.
•Performance of HARMONIE-AROME and WRF-ARW in four Tropical Transitions.•Track and intensity cyclone and spatial verification are evaluated.•HURDAT, MSG-SEVIRI and GPM-IMERG are used as observations.•Object-based method used to evaluate Brightness Temperature and accumulated precipitation.