Democratization and the diffusion of shari’a law Comparative insights from Indonesia

• Published in: South East Asia research Vol. 24; no. 2; pp. 261 - 282
• Main Authors: Buehler, Michael, Muhtada, Dani
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London, England SAGE Publishing in cooperation with the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London 01-06-2016; SAGE Publications; Taylor & Francis Group
• Subjects: Activism; Democracy; Democratization; Economic conditions; Fieldwork; Intergovernmental relations; Islam; Islamic countries; Islamization; Law; Local conditions; Middle Eastern cultural groups; Morality; Muslims; Networks; Political activism; Political parties; Politics; Proximity; Regulation; Religion & politics; Indonesia; Democratization; policy diffusion; Islamic law; Indonesia; Islamization; shari’a
• ISSN: 0967-828X; 2043-6874
• DOI: 10.1177/0967828X16649311

The democratization of politics has been accompanied by a rise of Islamic laws in many Muslim-majority countries. Despite a growing interest in the phenomenon, the Islamization of politics in democratizing Muslim-majority countries is rarely understood as a process that unfolds across space and time. Based on an original dataset established during years of field research in Indonesia, this article analyzes the spread of shari’a regulations across the world’s largest Muslim-majority democracy since 1998. The article shows that shari’a regulations in Indonesia diffused unevenly across space and time. Explanations put forward in the literature on the diffusion of morality policies in other countries such as geographic proximity, institutions, intergovernmental relations and economic conditions did not explain the patterns in the diffusion of shari’a regulations in Indonesia well. Instead, shari’a regulations in Indonesia were most likely to spread across jurisdictions where local Islamist groups situated outside the party system had an established presence. In short, the Islamization of politics was highly contingent on local conditions. Future research will need to pay more attention to local Islamist activists and networks situated outside formal politics as potential causes for the diffusion of shari’a law in democratizing Muslim-majority countries.