A method to assess the cloud-aerosol transition zone from ceilometer measurements

• Published in: Atmospheric research Vol. 310; p. 107623
• Main Authors: Ruiz de Morales, Jaume, Calbó, Josep, González, Josep-Abel, Sola, Yolanda
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier B.V 01-11-2024
• Subjects: Ceilometer; Cloud detection; Cloud vertical structure; Cloud-aerosol transition zone; Cloudnet; Twilight zone; Cloud detection; Ceilometer; Cloudnet; Cloud-aerosol transition zone; Cloud vertical structure; Twilight zone
• ISSN: 0169-8095
• DOI: 10.1016/j.atmosres.2024.107623

Cloud and aerosol contribution to the Earth's radiative budget constitutes one of the most significant uncertainties in future climate projections. To distinguish between clouds and cloud-free air, atmospheric scientists have been using a wide range of instruments, techniques, and algorithms with various detection thresholds. However, since the change from a cloudy to a cloud-free atmosphere may be gradual and, in some cases, far from obvious, recent research is questioning where the threshold between both phases should be established. These considerations lead to contemplate a transition zone (TZ) between cloud and cloud-free conditions. In the present study, backscatter profiles obtained by a Vaisala CL31 ceilometer were processed to assess the transition zone. First, two widely used cloud detection algorithms were applied and compared: the method provided by the ceilometer manufacturer (Vaisala) and Cloudnetpy, the algorithm from ACTRIS Cloudnet, a project devoted to aerosol, clouds, and trace gases research. Second, a sensitivity analysis was applied to the backscatter and signal-to-noise ratio thresholds used for cloud detection in Cloudnetpy. This methodology has allowed us to assess the vertical distribution of clouds, aerosols, the TZ, and its frequency of occurrence. Results indicate a gradual transition in backscatter retrievals from cloud to cloud-free, where particles detected near cloud boundaries induced higher backscatter values than those found further away. Depending on the thresholds used, we observed a 9.3% (with an estimated range of uncertainty of 5.420%) variation in cloud occurrence which can be attributed to TZ conditions. Analysing the whole backscatter profile, we found as many TZ conditions as cloudy values, which emphasises the importance of studying the vertical distribution of the TZ. Moreover, the analysis of TZ occurrence in height and time revealed that such conditions concentrate below 800m during night periods, although annual height-hour distributions involve a remarkable variability among seasons. These findings highlight the importance of either including an additional phase between ‘pure clouds’ and ‘pure aerosols’ or treating them as a continuum of suspended particles in the atmosphere.
•Ceilometer backscatter retrievals show a gradual transition from cloud to cloud-free.•Cloud detection is influenced by the set of thresholds used.•There is a 9.3% (5.420%) variation in cloud occurrence, attributed to TZ conditions.•The vertical analysis revealed that TZ conditions are as frequent as cloudy ones.•Cloud-aerosol TZ conditions were mainly found below 800 m during night periods.