Unusual causes of hyperthyrotropinemia and differential diagnosis of primary hypothyroidism: a revised diagnostic flowchart

• Published in: European thyroid journal Vol. 12; no. 4; pp. 1 - 12
• Main Authors: Campi, Irene, Dell’Acqua, Marco, Stellaria Grassi, Elisa, Cristina Vigone, Maria, Persani, Luca
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Bioscientifica Ltd 01-08-2023; Bioscientifica
• Subjects: assay artifacts; consumptive hypothyroidism; deiodinases; Diagnosis, Differential; Humans; hypothyroidism; Hypothyroidism - diagnosis; macro-tsh; malabsorption; Quality of Life; resistance to tsh; Review; Software Design; Thyrotropin; tsh; macro-TSH; consumptive hypothyroidism; hypothyroidism; resistance to TSH; TSH; malabsorption; deiodinases; assay artifacts
• ISSN: 2235-0802; 2235-0640; 2235-0802
• DOI: 10.1530/ETJ-23-0012

The clinical consequences of primary hypothyroidism include cardiovascular morbidity, increased mortality, and poor quality of life; therefore guidelines endorsed by several Scientific Societies recommend measuring circulating thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) in patients at risk. The assessment of serum TSH levels is also deemed to be the most robust and accurate biomarker during the management of replacement therapy in patients with a previous diagnosis of primary hypothyroidism. In line with a reflex TSH laboratory strategy, free thyroxine is measured only if the TSH falls outside specific cutoffs, in order to streamline investigations and save unjustified costs. This serum TSH-based approach to both diagnosis and monitoring has been widely accepted by several national and local health services; nevertheless, false-negative or -positive testing may occur, leading to inappropriate management or treatment. This review aims to describe several infrequent causes of increased circulating TSH, including analytical interferences, resistance to TSH, consumptive hypothyroidism, and refractoriness to levothyroxine replacement treatment. We propose a clinical flowchart to aid correct recognition of these various conditions, which represent important potential pitfalls in the diagnosis and treatment of primary hypothyroidism.