A Combined Tree Ring and Vegetation Model Assessment of European Forest Growth Sensitivity to Interannual Climate Variability

• Published in: Global biogeochemical cycles Vol. 32; no. 8; pp. 1226 - 1240
• Main Authors: Klesse, S., Babst, F., Lienert, S., Spahni, R., Joos, F., Bouriaud, O., Carrer, M., Di Filippo, A., Poulter, B., Trotsiuk, V., Wilson, R., Frank, D. C.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Washington Blackwell Publishing Ltd 01-08-2018
• Subjects: aboveground biomass increment; Annual variations; Biomass; Climate; Climate models; Climate sensitivity; Climate variability; Coefficient of variation; Dendrochronology; Environmental gradient; Forest biomass; Forest growth; Growth rate; Interannual variability; net primary productivity; Sensitivity analysis; Silvicultural practices; Silviculture; Switches; Temperature effects; Temperature rise; Tree growth; tree ring; Tree rings; Variability; Vegetation; vegetation model; Water demand
• ISSN: 0886-6236; 1944-9224
• DOI: 10.1029/2017GB005856

The response of forest growth to climate variability varies along environmental gradients. A growth increase and decrease with warming is usually observed in cold‐humid and warm‐dry regions, respectively. However, it remains poorly known where the sign of these temperature effects switches. Here we introduce a newly developed European tree ring network that has been specifically collected to reconstruct forest aboveground biomass increment (ABI). We quantify, how the long‐term (1910–2009) interannual variability of ABI depends on local mean May–August temperature and test, if a dynamic global vegetation model ensemble reflects the resulting patterns. We find that sites at 8 °C mean May–August temperature increase ABI on average by 5.7 ± 1.3%, whereas sites at 20 °C decrease ABI by 3.0 ± 1.8% m−2 year−1 Δ°C−1. A threshold temperature between beneficial and detrimental effects of warming and the associated increase in water demand on tree growth emerged at 15.9 ± 1.4 °C mean May–August temperature. Because interannual variability increases proportionally with mean growth rate—that is, the coefficient of variation stays constant—we were able to validate these findings with a much larger tree ring data set that had been established following classic dendrochronological sampling schemes. While the observed climate sensitivity pattern is well reflected in the dynamic global vegetation model ensemble, there is a large spread of threshold temperatures between the individual models. Also, individual models disagree strongly on the magnitude of climate impact at the coldest and warmest locations, suggesting where model improvement is most needed to more accurately predict forest growth and effectively guide silvicultural practices.
Key Points
Central and Northern European forest growth is expected to benefit (suffer) from additional warming in regions with a mean growing season temperature below (above) 15.9 plus‐minus 1.4 degrees Celsius
A vegetation model ensemble mean agrees with this threshold but is too sensitive to temperature changes at coldest and warmest locations
Model improvements are needed to predict forest growth more accurately and guide silvicultural practices