Noble gas fractionation during subsurface gas migration

• Published in: Earth and planetary science letters Vol. 450; no. C; pp. 1 - 9
• Main Authors: Sathaye, Kiran J., Larson, Toti E., Hesse, Marc A.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Netherlands Elsevier B.V 15-09-2016; Elsevier
• Subjects: Carbon capture and storage; Carbon dioxide; Enrichment; Fractionation; geochemical tracers; geological carbon storage; Migration; migration–fractionation; Noble gases; Rare gases; Shale gas; two-phase flow; geological carbon storage; shale gas; noble gases; geochemical tracers; migration–fractionation; two-phase flow
• ISSN: 0012-821X; 1385-013X
• DOI: 10.1016/j.epsl.2016.05.034

•Theoretical and experimental foundation for identification of fugitive gases from shale gas development.•Experiment, theory, and field data showing stripping of dissolved gases and banks of co-injected gases.•Experimental and theoretical description of the behavior of noble gases during two-phase flow.•Theory establishes new framework for the interpretation of noble gas data.•Field evidence and theory for chromatographic separations during subsurface gas transport.
Environmental monitoring of shale gas production and geological carbon dioxide (CO2) storage requires identification of subsurface gas sources. Noble gases provide a powerful tool to distinguish different sources if the modifications of the gas composition during transport can be accounted for. Despite the recognition of compositional changes due to gas migration in the subsurface, the interpretation of geochemical data relies largely on zero-dimensional mixing and fractionation models. Here we present two-phase flow column experiments that demonstrate these changes. Water containing a dissolved noble gas is displaced by gas comprised of CO2 and argon. We observe a characteristic pattern of initial co-enrichment of noble gases from both phases in banks at the gas front, followed by a depletion of the dissolved noble gas. The enrichment of the co-injected noble gas is due to the dissolution of the more soluble major gas component, while the enrichment of the dissolved noble gas is due to stripping from the groundwater. These processes amount to chromatographic separations that occur during two-phase flow and can be predicted by the theory of gas injection. This theory provides a mechanistic basis for noble gas fractionation during gas migration and improves our ability to identify subsurface gas sources after post-genetic modification. Finally, we show that compositional changes due to two-phase flow can qualitatively explain the spatial compositional trends observed within the Bravo Dome natural CO2 reservoir and some regional compositional trends observed in drinking water wells overlying the Marcellus and Barnett shale regions. In both cases, only the migration of a gas with constant source composition is required, rather than multi-stage mixing and fractionation models previously proposed.