Nonresidential Fatherhood and Father-Child Relationships Among Curaçaoan and Dutch Adolescents and Young Adults

• Published in: Journal of family psychology Vol. 38; no. 2; pp. 270 - 281
• Main Authors: Osinga, Mariëlle, van Brummen-Girigori, Odette J., van Bergen, Diana D., Kretschmer, Tina
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States American Psychological Association 01-03-2024
• Subjects: Adolescent; Attachment; Caribbean Cultural Groups; Child development; Cross Cultural Differences; Demography; Emerging Adulthood; Emotions; Family structure; Father Absence; Father Child Relations; Fathers; Fathers - psychology; Female; Human; Humans; Interpersonal relations; Interpersonal Relationships; Living Arrangements; Male; Measurement; Parenting - psychology; Parents & parenting; Quality; Social Class; Sociocultural Factors; Socioeconomic status; Stigma; Young Adult; Young adults; Youth; cross-country; nonresidential fatherhood; adolescents and young adults; Caribbean; father-child relationships
• ISSN: 0893-3200; 1939-1293; 1939-1293
• DOI: 10.1037/fam0001159

Growing up with a nonresident biological father has been portrayed as problematic for different aspects of father-child relationships, but it is unclear whether experiencing nonresidential fatherhood is less problematic in countries where this family structure is more common and thus probably less stigmatized. Cross-country research into nonresidential fatherhood is scarce, especially including Caribbean countries where many children grow up without their biological father in the home. This study examined associations between nonresidential fatherhood and father-child relationship quality and fathers' parenting behaviors among Curaçaoan and Dutch adolescents and young adults. Curaçaoan (n = 450) and Dutch (n = 585) participants completed a digital questionnaire in class, using the same procedures on Curaçao and in the Netherlands. We estimated structural equation models of perceived avoidant and anxious father-child attachment and paternal emotional warmth, rejection, and monitoring for both groups separately because of measurement variance across countries. Nonresidential fatherhood was unrelated to perceptions of most aspects of father-child relationships among both Curaçaoan and Dutch participants. This study adds an important cross-country perspective to the current literature on nonresidential fatherhood and tentatively suggests that correlates of nonresidential fatherhood for father-child relationships might be less evident than previous studies suggest. Instead, young people's socioeconomic status (SES) and the frequency of contact between fathers and children seem to be more important for father-child attachment and paternal rearing behaviors. Further research across demographic characteristics and child outcomes is required to understand whether, when, and how nonresidence of the biological father might affect child well-being and development in different countries.