Criminal Justice Outcomes of Suicide by Cop Survivors

• Published in: The journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law Vol. 51; no. 3; pp. 390 - 400
• Main Author: Weiss, Kenneth J
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States 01-09-2023
• Subjects: police-assisted suicide; therapeutic jurisprudence; suicide by cop; criminal responsibility; mental health court
• ISSN: 1943-3662
• DOI: 10.29158/JAAPL.220116-22

The concept of suicide by cop (SbC) is of interest to psychiatrists, law enforcement professionals, lawyers, and citizens. It is a form of provoked homicide arising from a wish to die. Those who attempt SbC experience more mental illness, substance use, and recent trauma than the general population. This article examines those who attempt SbC and survive the encounters. SbC survivors who threaten or harm police or others may be charged with crimes such as weapons possession, aggravated assault, murder or attempted murder of an officer. The formulation of a provocative act, however, frustrates attempts at defenses based on mental state, resulting in few requests for expert testimony. Few data exist on how these individuals fare in court. Appellate cases in which defendants attempted to introduce evidence of SbC illustrate great variability in adjudication. Psychiatric defenses, such as diminished capacity and insanity, are usually inapplicable or unsuccessful because intent and knowledge of wrongfulness are implied in the provocative act. Diversion of SbC defendants into mental health courts is rare because of firearms use against police. The author argues that criminal justice ignores SbC survivors' mental health and recommends application of therapeutic jurisprudence to give full expression of SbC dynamics.