Evolution of parasitism among closely related species: phylogenetic relationships and the origin of inquilinism in gall wasps (Hymenoptera: Cynipidae)

• Published in: Evolution Vol. 48; no. 2; pp. 241 - 266
• Main Author: Ronquist, F. (Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden)
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Society for the Study of Evolution 01-04-1994; Oxford University Press
• Subjects: AGALLAS; Agastoparasitism; Biological taxonomies; convergence; CYNIPIDAE; diastrophus; Emery's rule; Entomology; Evolution; FILOGENIA; gall wasps; GALLE; Genera; HOSTS; HOTE; HUESPEDES; Hymenoptera; Inquilinism; PARASITE; Parasite hosts; PARASITES; PARASITISM; PARASITISME; PARASITISMO; PARASITOS; PHYLOGENIE; PHYLOGENY; Physiological aspects; Plant gall; PLANT GALLS; Social parasitism; Wasps; Cynipidae; Agastoparasitism; convergence; gall wasps; Emery's rule; phylogeny; evolution; inquilinism
• ISSN: 0014-3820; 1558-5646
• DOI: 10.1111/j.1558-5646.1994.tb01310.x

A new term, agastoparasitism, is proposed for parasitism among closely related species. Cynipid inquilines are typical agastoparasites. They cannot induce galls; instead their larvae live inside the galls formed by other cynipids. As in many other groups of agastoparasites, there are two competing hypotheses for the evolutionary origin of cynipid inquilines: either they arose from one of their cynipid hosts, and later radiated to exploit other gall-inducing cynipids (monophyletic origin), or they arose repeatedly, each inquiline from its host (polyphyletic origin). These hypotheses for the origin of cynipid inquilines were tested by a phylogenetic analysis of representative species of cynipid gall inducers and inquilines based on adult morphological characters. The analysis supported the monophyly of the inquilines and indicated an origin from gall inducers related to the genus Diastrophus, one of the current host groups. To examine whether the result of the analysis was influenced by convergent similarities among inquilines because of their similar mode of life, all putative apomorphies shared by some or all of the inquilines but not occurring in any of the gall inducers were removed. Despite this, the phylogenetic conclusions essentially remained the same, that is, the support for inquiline monophyly was not caused by convergent evolution. Based on these results, adaptive aspects of the evolutionary origin and maintenance of cynipid inquilinism are discussed, as well as general patterns in the evolution of agastoparasitism.