Hyperbrain features of team mental models within a juggling paradigm: a proof of concept

• Published in: PeerJ (San Francisco, CA) Vol. 4; p. e2457
• Main Authors: Filho, Edson, Bertollo, Maurizio, Tamburro, Gabriella, Schinaia, Lorenzo, Chatel-Goldman, Jonas, di Fronso, Selenia, Robazza, Claudio, Comani, Silvia
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States PeerJ. Ltd 20-09-2016; PeerJ, Inc; PeerJ Inc
• Subjects: Analysis; Behavior; Brain; Brain research; Cognitive ability; Complementary mental models; EEG; Functional connectivity; Functional morphology; Graph theory analysis; Hyperscanning; Information processing; International organizations; Juggling paradigm; Kinesiology; Laboratories; Memory; Neural networks; Neuroscience; Neurosciences; Physiological aspects; Psychiatry and Psychology; Shared mental models; Social behavior; Studies; Functional connectivity; Graph theory analysis; Juggling paradigm; Complementary mental models; Shared mental models; Social neuroscience; Hyperscanning; Team mental models
• ISSN: 2167-8359; 2167-8359
• DOI: 10.7717/peerj.2457

Research on cooperative behavior and the social brain exists, but little research has focused on real-time motor cooperative behavior and its neural correlates. In this proof of concept study, we explored the conceptual notion of shared and complementary mental models through EEG mapping of two brains performing a real-world interactive motor task of increasing difficulty. We used the recently introduced participative "juggling paradigm," and collected neuro-physiological and psycho-social data. We were interested in analyzing the between-brains coupling during a dyadic juggling task, and in exploring the relationship between the motor task execution, the jugglers'skill level and the task difficulty. We also investigated how this relationship could be mirrored in the coupled functional organization of the interacting brains.
To capture the neural schemas underlying the notion of shared and complementary mental models, we examined the functional connectivity patterns and hyperbrain features of a juggling dyad involved in cooperative motor tasks of increasing difficulty. Jugglers' cortical activity was measured using two synchronized 32-channel EEG systems during dyadic juggling performed with 3, 4, 5 and 6 balls. Individual and hyperbrain functional connections were quantified through coherence maps calculated across all electrode pairs in the theta and alpha bands (4-8 and 8-12 Hz). Graph metrics were used to typify the global topology and efficiency of the functional networks for the four difficulty levels in the theta and alpha bands.
Results indicated that, as task difficulty increased, the cortical functional organization of the more skilled juggler became progressively more segregated in both frequency bands, with a small-world organization in the theta band during easier tasks, indicative of a flow-like state in line with the neural efficiency hypothesis. Conversely, more integrated functional patterns were observed for the less skilled juggler in both frequency bands, possibly related to cognitive overload due to the difficulty of the task at hand (reinvestment hypothesis). At the hyperbrain level, a segregated functional organization involving areas of the visuo-attentional networks of both jugglers was observed in both frequency bands and for the easier task only.
These results suggest that cooperative juggling is supported by integrated activity of specialized cortical areas from both brains only during easier tasks, whereas it relies on individual skills, mirrored in uncorrelated individual brain activations, during more difficult tasks. These findings suggest that task difficulty and jugglers' personal skills may influence the features of the hyperbrain network in its shared/integrative and complementary/segregative tendencies.