Comparing the Productivity of the Latest Models of Li-Ion Battery and Petrol Chainsaws in a Conifer Clear-Cut Site

• Published in: Forests Vol. 14; no. 3; p. 585
• Main Authors: Andrea Laschi, Francesco Neri, Elena Marra, Fabio Fabiano, Niccolò Frassinelli, Enrico Marchi, Riccardo Paoloni, Cristiano Foderi
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: MDPI AG 01-03-2023
• Subjects: battery; chainsaw; conifer clear-cut; petrol; productivity investigation
• ISSN: 1999-4907
• DOI: 10.3390/f14030585

The recent technological development of batteries has allowed the production of powerful tools that are also used in forestry operations. For this reason, this study aimed to compare the performance of two latest chainsaw models in a conifer clear-cut. The examined chainsaws, the battery-powered Stihl MSA 300 and the petrol-powered MS 261 C-M, have comparable power and weight. The overall working times were recorded and then gross, net and felling/processing productivities were quantified. Our findings reported that in a working day (7.4 h gross time), each chainsaw felled and processed an average of 20 trees of 0.64 m3 with an average diameter at breast height of 28 cm. Considering the net productivity, no statistically significant differences were recorded between the two chainsaws. Investigating the productivities on operations conducted using the chainsaws, the battery chainsaw showed a lower average tree-processing productivity than that recorded for the petrol chainsaw. On average, the battery duration was 0.88 h, while the petrol tank duration was 0.97 h. Our study shows that battery chainsaws have great potential in forestry operations; however, considering the actual need for 8 charges per standard workday, optimizing battery management is an important objective for future work.