Previous beliefs affect Bayesian reasoning in conditions fostering gist comprehension

• Published in: Memory & cognition Vol. 51; no. 8; pp. 1819 - 1835
• Main Authors: Tubau, Elisabet, Colomé, Àngels, Rodríguez-Ferreiro, Javier
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: New York Springer US 01-11-2023; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Bayesian analysis; Behavioral Science and Psychology; Cognitive Psychology; Credibility; Estimates; Hypotheses; Mathematical problems; Numbers; Probability; Psychology; Ratios; Gist comprehension; Bayesian reasoning; Presentation format; Nonnumerical probability estimates; Belief effect
• ISSN: 0090-502X; 1532-5946
• DOI: 10.3758/s13421-023-01435-1

It has been shown that Bayesian reasoning is affected by the believability of the data, but it is unknown which conditions could potentiate or reduce such belief effect. Here, we tested the hypothesis that the belief effect would mainly be observed in conditions fostering a gist comprehension of the data. Accordingly, we expected to observe a significant belief effect in iconic rather than in textual presentations and, in general, when nonnumerical estimates were requested. The results of three studies showed more accurate Bayesian estimates, either expressed numerically or nonnumerically, for icons than for text descriptions of natural frequencies. Moreover, in line with our expectations, nonnumerical estimates were, in general, more accurate for believable rather than for unbelievable scenarios. In contrast, the belief effect on the accuracy of the numerical estimates depended on the format and on the complexity of the calculation. The present findings also showed that single-event posterior probability estimates based on described frequencies were more accurate when expressed nonnumerically rather than numerically, opening new avenues for the development of interventions to improve Bayesian reasoning.