Alien turf: Overfishing, overgrazing and invader domination in south‐eastern Levant reef ecosystems

• Published in: Aquatic conservation Vol. 28; no. 2; pp. 351 - 369
• Main Authors: Rilov, Gil, Peleg, Ohad, Yeruham, Erez, Garval, Tal, Vichik, Ania, Raveh, Ofrat
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Oxford Wiley Subscription Services, Inc 01-04-2018
• Subjects: Algae; alien species; Biodiversity; Catch per unit effort; Climate change; coastal; Commercial species; Conservation; Ecological function; Ecological monitoring; Ecosystem restoration; Ecosystems; Fish; Fishing; Fishing effort; Fishing pressure; Indigenous species; Introduced species; Invasive species; Marine ecosystems; Marine parks; marine protected areas; Mollusks; Native organisms; Nature reserves; Overfishing; Plant cover; Polls & surveys; Potential resources; Predators; Preservation; Pressure; Reefs; Restoration; Shellfish; Substrates; Surveying; Surveys; Turf; Wildlife conservation; Levant (historic region); Mediterranean Sea
• ISSN: 1052-7613; 1099-0755
• DOI: 10.1002/aqc.2862

Coastal reefs are highly diverse marine ecosystems that in many regions suffer today from growing pressures by human activities. Among the most highly‐stressed are those found in the Levantine basin (south‐eastern Mediterranean Sea). The Levant represents the trailing‐edge of distribution of native species where they are exposed to the most extreme temperature and salinity conditions, and the region is also fast‐warming and exposed to a great many alien species and strong fishing pressure. In this study, the ecological state of reefs in the south‐eastern Levant was assessed quantitatively (including inside a small marine reserve) using current, extensive, survey data with reference to anecdotal historical information on their more pristine past.
The results of very extensive subtidal community surveys that were conducted in north Israel indicate that reefs in this area are currently dominated by turf‐forming algae and aliens, and sustain low numbers of top predators. Specifically, it was found that on these Levant reefs: (1) commercial species represent a very small part of the fish assemblage (except inside the reserve); (2) alien species constitute a considerable portion (23–44%) of the fish assemblage (including in the reserve) and 95–99% of epi‐benthic molluscs, including inside the marine reserve; and (3) turf barrens are the dominant substrate cover, while cover of native brown algae canopy is limited to small patches occurring only during winter and spring.
These findings suggest that the Levant reefs have been highly transformed by overfishing and alien invasions, and probably also climate change, and that even well managed marine reserves had little effect on alien species presence. From a biogeographic‐conservation perspective, as both warming and bioinvasions continue in the Mediterranean, it is expected that this degraded reef state will gradually advance westward. Alleviating fishing pressure with marine reserves might make the reefs more resilient to these regional pressures, but alien invaders will remain a dominant feature in the system. Therefore, a more realistic conservation target might be the preservation or restoration of ecosystem functions rather than the original native biodiversity.