Hospital-based health technology assessment on the use of mitral clips in the treatment of mitral regurgitation

• Published in: Technology and health care Vol. 21; no. 6; p. 535
• Main Authors: Miniati, Roberto, Cecconi, Giulio, Dori, Fabrizio, Marchetti, Matteo, Gentili, Guido Biffi, Porchia, Barbara, Presicce, Giorgio, Franchi, Sara, Gusinu, Roberto
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Netherlands 01-01-2013
• Subjects: Cardiac Surgical Procedures - economics; Cardiac Surgical Procedures - instrumentation; Cardiac Surgical Procedures - methods; Hospital Costs - statistics & numerical data; Humans; Italy; Minimally Invasive Surgical Procedures - economics; Minimally Invasive Surgical Procedures - instrumentation; Minimally Invasive Surgical Procedures - methods; Mitral Valve Insufficiency - economics; Mitral Valve Insufficiency - surgery; Surgical Instruments - economics; Surgical Instruments - standards; Technology Assessment, Biomedical - economics; Technology Assessment, Biomedical - methods; Technology Assessment, Biomedical - standards; Italy; hospital based; Health technology assessment; mitral regurgitation; mitral clips
• ISSN: 1878-7401
• DOI: 10.3233/THC-130756

This study, carried out at the Florence Teaching Hospital Careggi (AOUC), reports the technological evaluation, through the use of Health Technology Assessment (HTA), on the application of mitral clips in the treatment of mitral insufficiency.
The assessment, carried out by analyzing the clinical, technological, social, procedural, safety and economic elements, sought to answer the following research questions: Evaluation of the general technological status of the mitral clips in the treatment process of mitral regurgitation, with particular reference to traditional methods; and contextualisation of the analyses within the hospital structure, by identifying criticality issues and improvements.
The methodology was based on the following steps: technological description; areas of evaluation and the selection of Key Performance Indicators; research of scientific facts and the collection of expert opinions; evaluation and reporting of findings.
The results are based on an analysis which included a total of 50 indicators, effectively evaluating 86.5% of them, from the least from the clinical sector (80%) to the most in the areas of procedure, safety and social (100%). Traditional surgery (repair or valve replacement) still represents the gold standard for the treatment of mitral regurgitation due to its maturity both on a technological and clinical level. The minimally invasive procedures which use the mitral clips present interesting opportunities both on a social level (minimum stay in hospital and no post-operative rehabilitation) and clinical level, especially as an alternative to medication, even if they are still at an emergent level (the long-term results are unknown) and complex to use. From the clinical point of view they show some interesting findings related to immediate and post-operative mortality (none during the operation and a minor and equal amount 30 days and 12 months later in comparison to traditional methods) whilst economically, despite the fact that the cost of the device is greater than those used in traditional interventions, the cost-refund relationship does not show significant differences compared to the traditional types of treatment.
The HTA evaluation of minimally invasive technologies that use clips for the treatment of mitral regurgitation shows, in the hospital setting, very interesting results, particularly for inoperable patients, where the clinical and social improvements are significant compared to pharmacological treatments, whilst for 'operable' patients, the traditional techniques are still the most appropriate.