Transformation of Learning from Real to Virtual: An Exploratory-Descriptive Analysis of Issues and Challenges

• Published in: Journal of research in innovative teaching Vol. 14; no. 1; pp. 5 - 17
• Main Authors: Rizvi, Yasmeen Shamsi, Nabi, Asma
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Bingley Emerald Publishing Limited 01-01-2021; Emerald Group Publishing Limited; Emerald Publishing
• Subjects: Barriers; College Students; Colleges & universities; Computer Use; COVID-19; covid-19 pandemic; Distance learning; education; Educational Environment; Educational Quality; Educational Research; Educational Technology; Electronic Learning; Family Environment; Foreign Countries; In Person Learning; Interaction; Internet; Internet access; Learning Processes; Online Courses; Online instruction; online teaching and learning; Pandemics; School closures; Social Isolation; Student Attitudes; Students; Teaching; Teaching Methods; Technical Education; technology; university online classes; Virtual Universities; India; United States > US
• ISSN: 1947-1017; 2397-7604; 1947-1017; 2397-7604
• DOI: 10.1108/JRIT-10-2020-0052

Purpose: As online teaching/learning is a new phenomenon with reference to regular degree programs in institutions of higher education in India (the situation having being thrust upon both students and faculty due to COVID-19 pandemic), an exploratory-descriptive study was carried out to find out how public university students in India perceive online teaching/learning (OTL) during the present pandemic, the methods of OTL being used by faculty and the challenges being faced by the students. Design/methodology/approach: Online interviews with 40 students of three public universities in Delhi/NCR were conducted using open-ended and close-ended questions. The questionnaire was emailed to 82 university students of Commerce and Management specialisation out of which 40 responded. We analysed each participants interview responses using content analysis technique and categorised the themes/factors that emerged under suitable headings using the coding method. The frequencies of the occurrence of the themes/factors were thus determined and documented, and percentages were calculated. The questionnaire also had Likert-scale questions as they are useful to measure latent constructs. Findings: Inadequate bandwidth and poor network connectivity were found to be major hindrances during OT/L. The other challenges were unsuitable home environment for attending online classes, feeling of isolation and demotivation due to lack of face-to-face interaction and excessive screen-time causing fatigue. Active online methods such as live lectures by faculty and article/case study/discussions facilitated live by faculty were most preferred while the passive method of learning such as online certification courses through education portals such as Swayam/ Coursera/Udemy, etc were least preferred. The level of satisfaction from student--faculty interaction was more than that from student--student interaction. Research limitations/implications: The study covered three public universities in India and the sample size was small because of limitations created by COVID-19 pandemic situation as campuses were closed and it was not possible to meet students personally to get responses. Practical implications: Universities should provide data cards or access to university computer labs to those students who are from economically weaker sections of society so that online teaching may be effective. This will also help students who live in very small houses and do not have a quiet corner to study online. Other solution would be to reduce online teaching duration. This issue needs the attention of educational institution leaders as most universities have scheduled classes from morning till evening, as it was during real classroom teaching. Eight hours of online classes every day may not be feasible when Internet access is a critical problem. Teachers should encourage interaction between students so that the feeling of isolation may be reduced and students may be motivated to learn and take more interest in virtual classes. Social implications: 50% of the Indian population does not have access to the Internet, while a large section that does have, cannot afford the cost of high-speed data that is needed for long-duration online classes spanning over months. Those who can afford it, do not have the privacy to engage effectively in classes on video conferencing portals. Both students and teachers suffer due to poor audio and video quality caused by poor infrastructure. COVID-19 has brought to focus, the severe inequality in some societies. Societies need to take serious cognizance of this issue and take appropriate measures. Originality/value: This study is very unique as the radical change from real classroom to online teaching in Indian public universities is a very unique phenomenon. The disruption was forced due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic and students along with their teachers learned the process "on-the-job". As the issues and challenges faced by students were unexplored, this study aims to contribute knowledge to this existing research gap.