Factors Associated with Confirmed and Unconfirmed Autism Spectrum Disorder Diagnosis in Children Volunteering for Research

• Published in: Journal of autism and developmental disorders
• Main Authors: Duvall, Susanne W, Greene, Rachel K, Phelps, Randi, Rutter, Tara M, Markwardt, Sheila, Grieser Painter, Julia, Cordova, Michaela, Calame, Beth, Doyle, Olivia, Nigg, Joel T, Fombonne, Eric, Fair, Damien
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States 12-04-2024
• Subjects: Accuracy; Community-based diagnosis; Diagnosis; Comorbidity; Autism spectrum disorder
• DOI: 10.1007/s10803-024-06329-y
• EISSN: 1573-3432
• ISSN: 0162-3257

Diagnostic accuracy of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is crucial to track and characterize ASD, as well as to guide appropriate interventions at the individual level. However, under-diagnosis, over-diagnosis, and misdiagnosis of ASD are still prevalent.
We describe 232 children (M
= 10.71 years; 19% female) with community-based diagnoses of ASD referred for research participation. Extensive assessment procedures were employed to confirm ASD diagnosis before study inclusion. The sample was subsequently divided into two groups with either confirmed ASD diagnoses (ASD+) or unconfirmed/inaccurate diagnoses (ASD-). Clinical characteristics differentiating the groups were further analyzed.
47% of children with community-based ASD diagnoses did not meet ASD criteria by expert consensus. ASD + and ASD- groups did not differ in age, gender, ethnicity, or racial make-up. The ASD + group was more likely to have a history of early language delays compared to the ASD- group; however, no group differences in current functional language use were reported by caregivers. The ASD + group scored significantly higher on ADI-R scores and on the ADOS-2 algorithm composite scores and calibrated severity scores (CSSs). The ASD- group attained higher estimated IQ scores and higher rates of psychiatric disorders, including anxiety disorder, disruptive behavior, and mood disorder diagnoses. Broadly, caregiver questionnaires (SRS-2, CCC-2) did not differentiate groups.
Increased reported psychiatric disorders in the ASD- group suggests psychiatric complexity may contribute to community misdiagnosis and possible overdiagnosis of ASD. Clinician-mediated tools (ADI-R, ADOS-2) differentiated ASD + versus ASD- groups, whereas caregiver-reported questionnaires did not.